Evolution, speciation and conservation conflicts
Studying this course? Keep your progress in one place.
Key facts
- Evolution is a change in allele frequency in a gene pool over generations.
- Mutation creates new alleles; natural selection increases the frequency of advantageous ones.
- Speciation needs reduced gene flow: allopatric (barrier) or sympatric (same area).
- Conclusions on controversial issues can be biased by vested interests; check peer review and declared funding.
- Reforestation and biofuels help but are only nearly carbon neutral.
Evolution and allele frequency
Evolution is a change in allele frequency in a population, produced by random mutation and then natural selection.
A gene pool is all the alleles of all the genes in a population. Evolution is a change in allele frequency over successive generations.
Mutation creates new alleles at random. Natural selection acts on the variation: individuals with advantageous alleles are more likely to survive and reproduce, so those alleles increase in frequency. Individuals do not evolve: populations do.
- Allele frequencycopies of the allele ÷ total alleles of that gene
- Diploid population of alleles of each gene
Worked example
In a sample of 100 flies there are 124 copies of allele A. Find its frequency.
- 1
Diploid, so there are 2 × 100 = 200 alleles of the gene.
- 2
Frequency = 124 ÷ 200.
In a diploid population of 50 individuals there are 30 copies of allele B. What is its frequency?
Speciation and gene flow
A new species forms when gene flow between populations is reduced and their allele frequencies diverge until they are reproductively isolated.
A species is a group of organisms that can interbreed to produce fertile offspring. Speciation is the formation of a new species. It happens when gene flow between populations is reduced; different mutations and selection pressures then change their allele frequencies until they cannot interbreed.
- 1
Reduced gene flow
populations stop interbreeding
- 2
Divergence
different mutations and selection pressures change allele frequencies
- 3
Reproductive isolation
they can no longer interbreed to produce fertile offspring
Allopatric speciation
- A geographical barrier such as a river, mountain range or sea separates populations in different environments
Sympatric speciation
- No geographical barrier: isolation from differences in breeding time, host plant, courtship behaviour or food source
Two insect populations in one forest mate on different host plants and diverge. Which type is this?
Controversial conclusions
Causes and solutions of climate change touch economic and political interests, so the same evidence can be read differently and bias must be checked.
The same evidence can lead to different conclusions. Vested interests, such as the funding source of a study, may bias interpretation, the selection of data or its presentation.
Groups may make different assumptions or use different boundaries, for example whether to include the carbon dioxide from land clearance in a biofuel calculation. Different priorities (economic growth, environment, food security) change how evidence is weighed. Correlations may be presented as proof of causation. Peer review helps to detect bias.
Builds trust
- Peer review by independent experts
- Published methods and data so results can be repeated
- Sufficient data, reducing chance effects
- Agreement with independent studies
Raises doubt
- Funding by a group with a vested interest
- Undeclared conflicts of interest
- Selected data or unusual boundaries
- Correlation presented as causation
Why might a study funded by a company with a stake in the result be less reliable?
Reforestation and sustainability
Trees store carbon and restore habitats, and biofuels are renewable, but both have limits that stop them being fully carbon neutral.
Reforestation is replanting cleared forest. Growing trees take up carbon dioxide by photosynthesis and store carbon in wood and soil, so forests act as a carbon sink. It also restores habitats, reduces soil erosion and regulates water cycles.
A sustainable resource is replaced as fast as it is used, so future needs are not compromised. Biofuels, such as ethanol from sugar cane and biodiesel from oil crops, are renewable and nearly carbon neutral: the carbon dioxide released on burning was taken up as the crop grew.
Benefits
- Carbon stored in wood and soil
- Habitats restored, less erosion
- Biofuel crops can be regrown
Limits
- New forest takes decades to store much carbon
- Single-species plantations support less biodiversity
- Fossil fuels used to grow, process and transport the crop
- Forest or peat cleared for biofuel crops releases carbon, and food land is diverted
Why are biofuels only nearly carbon neutral?
Try an exam question
Describe how allopatric speciation can lead to the formation of a new species.
[4 marks]
- [1]A geographical barrier separates populations, so gene flow is reduced.
- [1]The populations experience different environments and selection pressures.
- [1]Different mutations arise, and allele frequencies diverge.
- [1]The populations can no longer interbreed to produce fertile offspring, so they are reproductively isolated.
That's the notes covered.
Carry on to the next subtopic.
Try a question
Which of the following is the best definition of evolution?
1 mark, marked against the mark scheme
Which of the following is the best definition of evolution?
1 mark, marked against the mark scheme