Classification and the three-domain system

Classification and the three-domain system

Spec 4.14 · Edexcel International A Level Biology: Revision notes

Studying this course? Keep your progress in one place.

Key facts

  • A species can interbreed to produce fertile offspring; this fails for asexual organisms and fossils.
  • Phenotypic evidence uses observable features; genotypic evidence uses DNA, RNA or protein sequences.
  • Molecular evidence is objective and quantitative; fewer differences mean a closer relationship.
  • Woese compared rRNA sequences and showed that the Archaea are a separate domain.
  • Bacteria have peptidoglycan walls, Archaea do not, and Eukarya have a nucleus.
  • New data are checked by peer review and repetition before groupings change.

The species concept

A species is a group of organisms that can interbreed to produce fertile offspring, but the definition has limits.

Classification arranges organisms into groups by similarity. The basic unit is the species: organisms with similar characteristics that interbreed to produce fertile offspring.

The definition has limitations, so other evidence is also used.

  1. 1

    Two organisms interbreed

    mating produces offspring

  2. 2

    Are the offspring fertile?

    fertile: the parents are one species

  3. 3

    Sterile offspring

    for example a mule: they are different species

  4. 4

    Limits

    asexual organisms and fossils cannot be tested

Testing the species definition

Limitation

  • Asexual organisms do not interbreed
  • Breeding cannot be tested on fossils
  • Hybrids can form and are often sterile (a mule)
  • Distant organisms cannot be tested

Why it matters

  • Bacteria reproduce asexually
  • No living animals to test
  • Some species interbreed
  • Cannot bring them together

Why is the interbreeding definition of species unsuitable for bacteria?

Phenotypic and genotypic similarity

Phenotypic grouping uses observable features; genotypic grouping uses base or amino acid sequences and is more objective.

Phenotypic similarity uses observable features such as structure and behaviour. It can mislead because similar features may evolve in unrelated organisms (convergent evolution), and individuals vary.

Genotypic similarity uses DNA or RNA base sequences or amino acid sequences. Closely related organisms have fewer differences because they share a more recent common ancestor.

0102030401ChimpanzeeRhesus monkeyHorseTunaYeastOrganismAmino acid differences
Amino acid differences in cytochrome c compared with humans (approximate classic data): fewer differences means closer relatives

Phenotypic

  • Observable features
  • Can mislead (convergent evolution)
  • More shared features = closer

Genotypic

  • DNA, RNA or amino acid sequences
  • Objective and quantitative
  • Fewer differences = closer

What does a smaller number of differences in DNA base sequence suggest?

Molecular evidence and Woese

In 1977 Woese compared rRNA sequences and found a group of prokaryotes as different from bacteria as from eukaryotes.

Scientists could compare DNA base sequences, ribosomal RNA and the amino acid sequences of proteins. Ribosomal RNA is in all living organisms and changes slowly, so it is useful for distant relationships.

In 1977 Carl Woese compared rRNA sequences. Some prokaryotes, previously grouped with bacteria, were as different from the bacteria as from the eukaryotes. This led to the three-domain system.

  1. 1

    Compare rRNA sequences

    rRNA is in all organisms and changes slowly

  2. 2

    Find a surprise

    some prokaryotes differ from bacteria as much as from eukaryotes

  3. 3

    Propose new groups

    the three-domain system (1977, Woese)

How rRNA evidence changed classification

Why is ribosomal RNA useful for comparing distantly related organisms?

The three domains

Bacteria, Archaea and Eukarya: two prokaryote domains and one eukaryote domain.

All living organisms are placed in one of three domains.

  • Bacteria: prokaryotes with peptidoglycan cell walls, circular DNA and 70S ribosomes.
  • Archaea: prokaryotes with no peptidoglycan, circular DNA and different membrane lipids; many live in extreme conditions such as hot springs. Their rRNA differs from both others.
  • Eukarya: eukaryotes with a membrane-bound nucleus, linear DNA, organelles and 80S ribosomes (protoctists, fungi, plants, animals).
  1. 1

    Is it a eukaryote?

    DNA linear in a nucleus, 80S ribosomes: Eukarya

  2. 2

    Is it a prokaryote?

    circular DNA, no nucleus

  3. 3

    Peptidoglycan cell wall?

    yes: Bacteria

  4. 4

    No peptidoglycan, distinct rRNA

    Archaea

Placing an organism in a domain

Bacteria

Cell type:
Prokaryote
Cell wall:
Peptidoglycan
DNA:
Circular
Ribosomes:
70S

Archaea

Cell type:
Prokaryote
Cell wall:
No peptidoglycan
DNA:
Circular
Ribosomes:
Distinct rRNA

Eukarya

Cell type:
Eukaryote
Cell wall:
Varies by group
DNA:
Linear, in a nucleus
Ribosomes:
80S

Which domain has a cell wall without peptidoglycan and no nucleus?

Evaluating new data

New classification evidence is peer reviewed and repeated before groupings are changed.

New evidence must be critically evaluated.

The work is published and peer reviewed, so other scientists check methods and conclusions. Others repeat it and look for further evidence, such as different genes or proteins, to see whether the results are reproducible. The data are accepted only if supported and if they explain more than the earlier system.

Classification is therefore revised as knowledge changes, as in the move from two and five kingdoms to three domains.

  1. 1

    Publish

    the work is peer reviewed

  2. 2

    Repeat

    other scientists look for further evidence

  3. 3

    Check reproducibility

    do the results hold?

  4. 4

    Accept or reject

    accepted only if supported and it explains more

How new evidence is evaluated

Why is new classification evidence peer reviewed?

Try an exam question

Explain how molecular evidence led to the three-domain system of classification.

[4 marks]

That's the notes covered.

Carry on to the next subtopic.

Try a question

Which statement defines a species?

1 mark, marked against the mark scheme

Revision notes