Interpreting health data and risk perception

Interpreting health data and risk perception

Spec 1.15–17 · Edexcel International A Level Biology: Revision notes

Studying this course? Keep your progress in one place.

Key facts

  • Morbidity is illness; mortality is death; incidence is new cases; prevalence is all cases.
  • Compare rates (such as per 100 000) rather than raw numbers when populations differ in size.
  • Correlation does not prove causation; look for confounding variables, a mechanism and consistent evidence.
  • Evaluate studies for sample selection and size, validity, reliability, duration and a control group.
  • Perceived risk often differs from actual risk.
  • Rate per 100 000number of casespopulation×100 000\dfrac{\text{number of cases}}{\text{population}} \times 100\,000

Illness and mortality data

Use rates, such as cases per 100 000, so that populations of different sizes can be compared fairly.

Morbidity is illness; mortality is death. Incidence is the number of new cases in a given time; prevalence is the total number of cases at a point in time. Compare rates, not raw numbers, because populations differ in size.

0100200300400500Town ATown BTownCases per 100 000
Illustrative: town A has 500 cases in 100 000 people; town B has 900 cases in 300 000 people. B has more cases but a lower rate.
  • Rate per 100 000number of casespopulation×100 000\dfrac{\text{number of cases}}{\text{population}} \times 100\,000

Worked example

There are 900 deaths in a population of 3 000 000. The earlier rate was 50 per 100 000. Find the new rate and the percentage change.

Why compare rates rather than numbers of cases?

Correlation and causation

A correlation is only a relationship; a confounding variable may affect both factors, so causation needs stronger evidence.

A correlation is a relationship between two variables. It does not prove causation, because a confounding variable such as age or smoking may affect both.

Causation is more likely if there is a known mechanism (LDL in plaques), a dose-response relationship, consistent results from several studies, and controlled trials showing a change. Conflicting evidence arises from differences in sample, method, control of confounders and bias; weigh many studies, preferably with peer review.

  1. 1

    Confounding variable

    For example age or smoking.

  2. 2

    Affects both factors

    It influences factor X and outcome Y.

  3. 3

    X and Y are correlated

    They change together.

  4. 4

    No proof of causation

    Look for a mechanism, dose-response and controlled trials.

A confounding variable can make two factors correlate

Correlation

  • A relationship between two variables
  • Does not show one causes the other

Evidence for causation

  • Known mechanism
  • Dose-response relationship
  • Consistent studies and controlled trials

A study finds a correlation between coffee drinking and CVD. What should you say?

Evaluating study design

Check the sample, sample size, validity, reliability, duration and whether there is a control group.

A sample should be random and representative (age, gender, ethnicity) to avoid bias. A larger sample reduces the effect of chance. Validity means the study measures what it claims to, with confounders controlled and accurate data (self-reported diets may not be). Reliability means similar results when repeated. Long enough duration and a control group allow comparison.

1020304050607080901000.20.40.60.81xyEffect of chance ∝ 1/√n
The effect of chance on a sample result shrinks as the sample size grows (proportional to 1/√n; relative scale).

Feature

  • Sample selection
  • Sample size
  • Validity
  • Reliability
  • Duration and control group

What to check

  • Random and representative
  • Larger reduces the effect of chance and anomalies
  • Measures what it claims to; confounders controlled
  • Similar results when repeated
  • Long enough, with a group for comparison

A study gives the same result each time it is repeated. Which quality is this?

Perceived and actual risk

Actual risk is calculated from data, but people judge risk by media coverage, familiarity, control and personal experience.

Actual risk is calculated from data on incidence and mortality. Perceived risk is a person's own judgement of how likely harm is.

The media give most attention to rare, dramatic events. People underestimate risks that are familiar or that they feel they control (diet, smoking) and overestimate involuntary or frightening ones. Personal experience, such as a relative with CVD, changes perception. Campaigns must give clear, accurate data.

  1. 1

    Actual risk

    Calculated from incidence and mortality data.

  2. 2

    Influences on perception

    Media coverage, familiarity, feeling of control, personal experience.

  3. 3

    Perceived risk

    A personal judgement, over- or underestimating the true risk.

  4. 4

    Campaigns

    Must give clear, accurate data.

Why perceived risk differs from actual risk

Actual risk

  • Calculated from incidence and mortality data
  • The true likelihood of harm

Perceived risk

  • A person's own judgement
  • Shaped by media, familiarity, control and experience

Why might people underestimate the risk from smoking?

Try an exam question

A study finds a correlation between salt intake and CVD. Explain why this does not prove that salt causes CVD, and how the evidence could be strengthened.

[4 marks]

That's the notes covered.

Carry on to the next subtopic.

Try a question

What is meant by the term mortality?

1 mark, marked against the mark scheme

Revision notes