Dimensions and consistency

Dimensions and consistency

Spec MA1–MA2 · AQA A-Level Further Maths: Revision notes

Studying this course? Keep your progress in one place.

Key facts

  • The base dimensions are mass MM, length LL and time TT; [x][x] means the dimensions of xx.
  • Multiplying adds powers; dividing subtracts them.
  • Speed LT−1LT^{-1}, acceleration LT−2LT^{-2}, force MLT−2MLT^{-2}, energy ML2T−2ML^2T^{-2}.
  • An equation is dimensionally consistent if every term has the same dimensions; this is necessary, not sufficient.
  • Angles, ratios and the argument of sin⁡\sin, ln⁡\ln or exe^x are dimensionless.

Base dimensions

Every mechanical quantity is built from mass MM, length LL and time TT.

Every mechanical quantity is built from three base dimensions: mass MM, length LL and time TT.

The dimensions of a quantity xx are written [x][x]. For example [mass]=M[\text{mass}]=M, [distance]=L[\text{distance}]=L, [time]=T[\text{time}]=T.

Dimensions describe the kind of quantity, not its units: speed has dimensions LT−1LT^{-1} whether it is measured in m s⁻¹ or km h⁻¹.

To find the dimensions of a new quantity, write down a defining equation, substitute the dimensions of each symbol, and combine the powers. When quantities are multiplied their powers of MM, LL and TT add; when divided, they subtract.

  1. 1

    Speed = distance ÷ time

    LT⁻¹

  2. 2

    Acceleration = speed ÷ time

    LT⁻²

  3. 3

    Force = mass × acceleration

    MLT⁻²

Dimensions build up from M, L and T through defining equations.
  • SpeedLT−1LT^{-1}
  • AccelerationLT−2LT^{-2}
  • ForceMLT−2MLT^{-2}

What are the dimensions of density (mass per unit volume)?

Dimensions of common quantities

Build each from its definition, and remember that pure numbers and angles are dimensionless.

Build these from definitions and learn the results.

A quantity with no dimensions (power zero for MM, LL and TT) is dimensionless. Pure numbers such as 12\frac12 or 2π2\pi, angles in radians, ratios such as the coefficient of restitution ee, and the argument of any sin⁡\sin, ln⁡\ln or exponential function are all dimensionless. Also [extdensity]=ML−3[ ext{density}]=ML^{-3} and [extfrequency]=T−1[ ext{frequency}]=T^{-1}; impulse and spring stiffness are in the table.

−3−2−1012ForceEnergyPowerPressureQuantityPower of M, L or T
  • M
  • L
  • T
The power of M, L and T in the dimensions of four common quantities.

How to build it

Force:
F=maF=ma
Momentum, impulse:
mvmv, FtFt
Work, energy:
force × distance
Power:
energy ÷ time
Pressure:
force ÷ area
Stiffness kk:
F=kxF=kx

Dimensions

Force:
MLT−2MLT^{-2}
Momentum, impulse:
MLT−1MLT^{-1}
Work, energy:
ML2T−2ML^{2}T^{-2}
Power:
ML2T−3ML^{2}T^{-3}
Pressure:
ML−1T−2ML^{-1}T^{-2}
Stiffness kk:
MT−2MT^{-2}

What are the dimensions of pressure?

Checking consistency

Find the dimensions of each term separately and compare; consistency is necessary but cannot detect a wrong numerical factor.

An equation is dimensionally consistent if both sides have the same dimensions, and every term added or subtracted has the same dimensions. Only quantities with the same dimensions can be added, subtracted or equated.

Method: find the dimensions of each term separately, then compare.

Dimensional consistency is a necessary test but not a sufficient one: it cannot detect a wrong numerical factor. s=ut+at2s=ut+at^2 is also consistent, yet incorrect.

  1. 1

    Split into terms

    each side, and each added or subtracted term

  2. 2

    Find dimensions of each term

    substitute M, L, T for every symbol

  3. 3

    Compare

    all terms must match

  4. 4

    Conclude

    necessary, but not sufficient, for a correct formula

Testing an equation for dimensional consistency.
  • Dimensionally consistentevery term has the same dimensions

Example

Is s=ut+12at2s=ut+\frac12at^2 dimensionally consistent?

Example

Kinetic energy is claimed to be E=12mvE=\frac12mv. Is this possible?

Is v2=u2+2asv^2=u^2+2as dimensionally consistent?

Predicting formulae

Write the quantity as a product of powers, then equate the powers of MM, LL and TT on both sides.

If you are told which quantities a result depends on, you can find the powers by dimensional analysis.

Write the quantity as a product x=λ apbqcrx=\lambda\,a^{p}b^{q}c^{r} where λ\lambda is a dimensionless constant, substitute dimensions, and equate the power of each of MM, LL and TT on both sides.

The method gives the form of the result and the powers, but not the value of λ\lambda; that needs an experiment or a full calculation.

  1. 1

    Write the form

    x = λ aᵖ bᵠ cʳ

  2. 2

    Substitute dimensions

    for x, a, b and c

  3. 3

    Equate powers

    of M, then L, then T

  4. 4

    Solve for p, q, r

    λ needs an experiment

Predicting a formula by dimensional analysis.
  • x=λ apbqcrx=\lambda\,a^{p}b^{q}c^{r}equate the powers of MM, LL and TT

Example

The period τ\tau of a simple pendulum depends on its length ll, mass mm and gg. Find the form of τ\tau.

A mass mm on a spring of stiffness kk (with [k]=MT−2[k]=MT^{-2}) has period τ=λmakb\tau=\lambda m^{a}k^{b}. Find aa and bb.

Dimensions of constants

Make the constant the subject of the formula, then substitute dimensions.

Rearrange the given formula to make the constant the subject, then substitute dimensions.

You can then use these dimensions to test other formulae.

  1. 1

    Make it the subject

    G = F r² ÷ (m₁m₂)

  2. 2

    Substitute dimensions

    F = MLT⁻², r = L, m = M

  3. 3

    Combine the powers

    G has dimensions M⁻¹L³T⁻²

Finding the dimensions of a constant such as G.
  • [G][G] from F=Gm1m2r2F=\dfrac{Gm_1m_2}{r^2}M−1L3T−2M^{-1}L^{3}T^{-2}

Example

Find [G][G] in Newton's law of gravitation F=Gm1m2r2F=\frac{Gm_1m_2}{r^2}.

Example

Air resistance is R=kv2R=kv^2. Find [k][k], then check the terminal speed V=mgkV=\sqrt{\frac{mg}{k}}.

Drag is modelled as F=kvF=kv. Find [k][k].

Try an exam question

Show that the formula T=2πlgT=2\pi\sqrt{\dfrac{l}{g}} for the period of a pendulum is dimensionally consistent.

[3 marks]

That's the notes covered.

Carry on to the next subtopic.

Try a question

What are the dimensions of v2r\frac{v^2}{r}?

1 mark, marked against the mark scheme

Revision notes