Edexcel International A Level Maths
Disproof by counter example
Total 27 marks
Name
Class
Date
- 1A statement T is made: for all real numbers , .(a)Which value of is a counterexample to T?[1 mark]
- A
- B
- C
- D
Show the mark scheme
Mark scheme
Answer: C(b)What is the smallest number of counterexamples needed to disprove T?[1 mark]- AOne
- BTwo
- CThree
- DEvery real number
Show the mark scheme
Mark scheme
Answer: A(c)Find a value of with and use it to show that T is false.[2 marks]Show the mark scheme
Mark scheme
M1: chooses a value (e.g. ) and substitutes into and
A1: e.g. is not greater than , so T is false
Accept: any value with and the correct comparison
Do not accept: a value that satisfies TTotal for question 1: 4 marks
- 2A student states: 'If is a prime number, then is also a prime number.'(a)Which value of is a counterexample to the statement?[1 mark]
- A
- B
- C
- D
Show the mark scheme
Mark scheme
Answer: D(b)The student finds that gives , which is prime. What does this show?[1 mark]- AThe statement is true for all primes
- BThe statement is not disproved by , but one agreeing case does not prove it
- CThe statement is false
- D is a counterexample
Show the mark scheme
Mark scheme
Answer: B(c)Find a counterexample to the statement with . Show your working.[2 marks]Show the mark scheme
Mark scheme
M1: chooses a prime and evaluates
A1: e.g. and , which is not prime
Accept: (), (), () or other valid primes
Do not accept: , or , where is primeTotal for question 2: 4 marks
- 3Consider the statement U: is a prime number for all integers .(a)Disprove U.[3 marks]
Show the mark scheme
Mark scheme
M1: substitutes values of into (until a non-prime is found)
A1: gives
B1: is not prime, so U is false
Accept: any valid counterexample with a correct factorisation(b)A student checks for U, finds (all prime) and concludes that U is true. (i) Explain why this conclusion is not valid. (ii) The student then claims that is prime for all integers . Find a counterexample to this claim.[4 marks]Show the mark scheme
Mark scheme
B1: (i) examples that agree with a statement do not prove it for all
B1: (i) a single counterexample is enough to disprove a statement
M1: (ii) evaluates for values of , e.g.
A1: (ii) gives , which is not prime
Accept: () or ()Total for question 3: 7 marks
- 4Statements about numbers can be disproved with a single counterexample. A calculator may be used.(a)Disprove each statement by giving a counterexample and showing that it works. (i) If and are real numbers with , then . (ii) is prime for all positive integers . (iii) for all real .[6 marks]
Show the mark scheme
Mark scheme
B1: (i) e.g. (any )
B1: (i) but
B1: (ii)
Accept: () or ()
B1: (ii) , which is not prime
B1: (iii) a non-zero value of , e.g.
B1: (iii) but
Do not accept: in (iii), where both sides equal 3(b)Dana claims that for all real . She tests and and the claim holds each time. (i) Explain why this is not a proof. (ii) Disprove the claim with a counterexample. (iii) Show that the claim is true only when .[6 marks]Show the mark scheme
Mark scheme
B1: (i) four examples cannot cover all real values of
B1: (i) all her values are positive, so she has not tested the other kinds of number (zero, negatives)
B1: (ii) a value , e.g.
B1: (ii) , which is not greater than
M1: (iii) expands to find
A1: (iii) only when
Accept: in (ii), where both sides equal 1Total for question 4: 12 marks
End of questions