Development of atomic models

Development of atomic models

IB MYP Sciences: Revision notes

Studying this course? Keep your progress in one place.

Key facts

  • A model is a simplified idea that explains evidence; it changes when new evidence appears.
  • Dalton (1803): atoms are tiny solid spheres. Thomson (1897): electrons found; the plum pudding model.
  • Rutherford (1909 to 1911): the gold foil experiment showed a tiny, dense, positive nucleus.
  • Bohr (1913): electrons orbit in fixed shells.
  • Changing models show science improving as evidence grows.

Why scientists use models

The atom is too small to see, so scientists build models to explain evidence and make predictions.

A model is a simplified picture or idea that explains evidence and can be used to make predictions. When new evidence cannot be explained, the model has to be changed. The atomic model has changed four main times, from Dalton to Bohr.

  1. 1

    Evidence

    observations from experiments

  2. 2

    Model

    a simplified idea that explains the evidence

  3. 3

    Predictions

    tested by new experiments

  4. 4

    New evidence

    that the model cannot explain, so it is changed

Then back to step 1

How models change

What happens when evidence does not fit a model?

Dalton: the solid sphere

Dalton suggested that all matter is made of tiny, solid spheres called atoms.

John Dalton's ideas (1803): atoms cannot be divided, all atoms of one element are identical, and atoms of different elements are different. The model explained why elements combine in fixed ratios, but said nothing about what is inside an atom.

Dalton

Dalton's solid sphere.

What did Dalton say about atoms?

Thomson: plum pudding

Thomson found electrons, so atoms could be divided; he proposed the plum pudding model.

J. J. Thomson found that a beam in a tube was made of tiny negatively charged particles, much smaller than atoms: electrons. Because atoms are neutral, his plum pudding model was a ball of positive charge with electrons embedded throughout, like plums in a pudding.

+++++++++−−−−−−−−

Plum pudding

Thomson's plum pudding model.
  1. 1

    Observation

    a beam made of tiny negative particles

  2. 2

    Conclusion

    electrons are smaller than atoms, so atoms can be divided

  3. 3

    Model

    a ball of positive charge with electrons embedded in it

Thomson's reasoning

What did Thomson discover?

Rutherford: the nuclear atom

Most alpha particles passed straight through, so atoms are mostly empty space with a tiny, dense, positive nucleus.

In the gold foil experiment, positively charged alpha particles were fired at very thin gold foil. The plum pudding model could not explain the results, because spread-out positive charge could only deflect the particles slightly. Rutherford concluded that all the positive charge and most of the mass is in a tiny nucleus at the centre.

+

Nuclear model

Rutherford's nuclear model.

Observation

  • Most alpha particles passed straight through
  • A few were deflected through large angles
  • About 1 in 8000 bounced almost straight back

Conclusion

  • Atoms are mostly empty space
  • A small, dense, positive nucleus repels them
  • The positive charge and most of the mass are in a tiny nucleus

What did the particles that bounced back show?

Bohr: electrons in shells

Bohr suggested electrons orbit the nucleus in fixed shells, at set distances.

Niels Bohr said an electron cannot be between shells. The evidence was that heated elements give out light of only certain colours, which fits electrons moving between fixed energy levels. The nuclear model could not explain this. The Bohr model is the shell model you use to write configurations such as 2,8,1.

Na11p 12n

Sodium atom

2,8,1

Bohr model of sodium.

What evidence supported Bohr's model?

Why models change

Models change when new evidence appears, which shows science improves as evidence grows.

A model is accepted because it explains the evidence available. Scientists test new models and other scientists check the work before it is accepted. Older models are still useful: the shell model is used to explain how atoms react.

  1. 1803

    Dalton

    Solid sphere.

  2. 1897

    Thomson

    Electrons found, so plum pudding.

  3. 1909-11

    Rutherford

    Gold foil results, so a nucleus.

  4. 1913

    Bohr

    Coloured light, so shells.

Why is the shell model still taught?

Try an exam question

Describe how the results of the gold foil experiment led Rutherford to the nuclear model of the atom.

[4 marks]

That's the notes covered.

Carry on to the next subtopic.

Try a question

The first panel is about John Dalton in 1803. How did Dalton picture an atom?

1 mark, marked against the mark scheme

Revision notes