Drug testing and antibiotics
Studying this course? Keep your progress in one place.
Key facts
- Withering’s 1785 digitalis tests were systematic but had no control group, were not blind and had no random allocation.
- Modern trials: lab tests, then Phase 1 (healthy volunteers, safety), Phase 2 (patients, effective dose), Phase 3 (many patients, compared with a placebo).
- In a double-blind trial neither patients nor researchers know who has the drug; allocation is random.
- Bacteria need nutrients, a suitable temperature, oxygen, moisture and pH; aseptic technique keeps cultures pure and safe.
- School cultures are incubated at no more than 25 °C to avoid growing human pathogens.
- A clear zone round a disc shows antimicrobial activity; area = .
Withering and digitalis
In 1785 Withering tested foxglove on over 100 patients, an early systematic trial, but with no control group, no blinding and no random allocation.
In the 1700s medicines were usually herbal mixtures given without systematic testing.
In 1785 William Withering studied a herbal remedy for dropsy (fluid retention) called digitalis soup. He identified foxglove (Digitalis purpurea) as the active ingredient and tested different doses on over 100 patients, recording doses, effects and side effects such as sickness and a very slow pulse. Digitalis is still the source of the heart drug digoxin.
Improvement could have been the placebo effect or doctor bias, not the drug.
| Withering | Modern trial | |
|---|---|---|
| Control group | No | Yes |
| Blind to who gets the drug | No | Yes |
| Random allocation of patients | No | Yes |
Withering
- Control group:
- No
- Blind to who gets the drug:
- No
- Random allocation of patients:
- No
Modern trial
- Control group:
- Yes
- Blind to who gets the drug:
- Yes
- Random allocation of patients:
- Yes
Give two weaknesses of Withering’s investigation of digitalis soup.
Modern clinical trials
New drugs pass laboratory tests, then three clinical phases that move from safety in healthy volunteers to effectiveness in large groups of patients.
Before human trials, a drug is tested in the laboratory on cells, tissues, computer models and animals to check for toxicity.
Clinical trials then follow three phases:
- Phase 1: a small number of healthy volunteers take low, then higher, doses to test safety, side effects, and how the drug is absorbed and removed.
- Phase 2: a small number of patients to find the effective dose and effects.
- Phase 3: a large number of patients, usually compared with a placebo or the best existing treatment, to confirm effectiveness and detect less common side effects.
Only if results are satisfactory is the drug licensed.
- 1
Laboratory tests
cells, tissues, computer models and animals check for toxicity
- 2
Phase 1
small number of healthy volunteers: safety and side effects
- 3
Phase 2
small number of patients: effective dose and effects
- 4
Phase 3
large number of patients, compared with a placebo or best treatment
- 5
Licence
granted only if the results are satisfactory
Which phase uses healthy volunteers?
Placebos and blind trials
A placebo control, double-blind testing and random allocation separate the effect of the drug from expectation and bias.
A placebo is an inactive substance that looks, tastes and is given in the same way as the drug. The group given it is the control, so the effect of the drug can be separated from the placebo effect.
In a double-blind trial neither the patients nor the researchers assessing them know who receives the drug and who the placebo, so expectation and bias cannot affect the results. The code is broken only after results are collected.
Patients are allocated to groups at random, so the groups are similar.
- 1
Random allocation
patients are assigned to groups by chance
- 2
Two groups
one gets the drug, the control group gets a placebo
- 3
Double-blind
neither patients nor researchers know who has the drug
- 4
Compare results
the difference is the effect of the drug
- Placebo controlseparates drug effect from placebo effect
- Double-blindneither patient nor researcher knows who has the drug
- Random allocationsimilar groups
Why are patients allocated to the drug and placebo groups at random?
Growing bacteria
Bacteria need nutrients, a suitable temperature, oxygen, moisture and pH, and then divide rapidly by binary fission.
Bacteria in culture need:
- Nutrients: carbon (for example glucose) and nitrogen (for example amino acids) in nutrient agar or broth.
- A suitable temperature: enzymes have an optimum. Human pathogens grow best at 37 °C, so school laboratories incubate at no more than about 25 °C.
- Oxygen for aerobic bacteria.
- Moisture and a suitable pH.
They then divide by binary fission and may double about every 20 minutes under ideal conditions.
Worked example
A culture starts with 100 bacteria and the population doubles every 20 minutes. How many bacteria are there after 1 hour?
- 1
1 hour is 60 minutes, which is 3 doubling times.
- 2
After 20 minutes: 100 × 2 = 200.
- 3
After 40 minutes: 200 × 2 = 400.
- 4
After 60 minutes: 400 × 2 = 800.
Why do school laboratories incubate cultures at no more than about 25 °C?
Aseptic technique
Aseptic technique stops other microorganisms contaminating the culture and stops the bacteria, which could be pathogens, escaping.
Aseptic technique prevents contamination of the culture and prevents the bacteria escaping.
- Disinfect the bench and wash hands before and after.
- Flame the bottle neck and the inoculating loop until red hot, then cool.
- Open the dish lid only slightly and briefly; use sterile equipment.
- Tape the lid with two pieces of tape, not all the way round, so air can enter, and invert the dish so condensation does not fall on the agar.
- Incubate at no more than 25 °C, then autoclave dishes unopened.
- 1
Prepare
disinfect the bench and wash hands
- 2
Sterilise
flame the loop and the neck of the bottle, then cool
- 3
Inoculate
open the lid only briefly
- 4
Seal
two pieces of tape, dish inverted
- 5
Incubate
no more than 25 °C
- 6
Dispose
autoclave dishes unopened
Why is the dish taped with two pieces of tape and not all the way round?
Core practical 9: plant antimicrobials
Soaked discs on a bacterial lawn give clear zones where growth is stopped; a larger zone area means a stronger antimicrobial effect.
Spread a lawn of bacteria on nutrient agar. Place paper discs soaked in plant extracts (such as garlic, mint or ginger) on it with sterile forceps. Add a positive control (antibiotic disc) and a negative control (sterile water or the solvent). Incubate inverted at 25 °C for 24 to 48 hours.
A clear zone forms where growth is stopped. Measure its diameter and calculate the area with .
Control disc size, extract volume and concentration, bacterial species, agar depth and temperature, and repeat for a mean.
- 1
Spread a lawn
bacteria on nutrient agar
- 2
Add discs
extracts, positive control, negative control
- 3
Incubate
inverted, 25 °C, 24 to 48 hours
- 4
Measure
diameter of each clear zone
- 5
Calculate
area =
Worked example
A clear zone has a diameter of 14 mm. Calculate its area.
- 1
Radius = 14 ÷ 2 = 7 mm.
- 2
Area = .
- 3
mm².
What is the purpose of the negative control disc soaked in sterile water?
Try an exam question
Describe how a clinical trial is designed to show whether a new drug is effective and safe.
[5 marks]
- [1]Phase 1 tests safety and side effects on a small number of healthy volunteers.
- [1]Phase 2 uses a small number of patients to find the effective dose.
- [1]Phase 3 uses a large number of patients, compared with a placebo or best existing treatment.
- [1]Patients are allocated to groups at random and the trial is double-blind.
- [1]This removes the placebo effect and bias, so any difference is due to the drug.
That's the notes covered.
Carry on to the next subtopic.
Try a question
Which is a weakness of Withering's method when compared with a modern drug trial?
1 mark, marked against the mark scheme
Which is a weakness of Withering's method when compared with a modern drug trial?
1 mark, marked against the mark scheme