Managing climate change and conservation
Studying this course? Keep your progress in one place.
Key facts
- On controversial issues, conclusions may depend on who reaches them: check funding, bias and peer review.
- Knowledge of the carbon cycle suggests ways to cut carbon dioxide: burn less fossil fuel, stop deforestation, replant, protect peat.
- Reforestation makes forests a carbon sink, and native species support more wildlife.
- Sustainable timber means replacing felled trees and selective felling.
- Biofuels are carbon neutral in principle, not wholly in practice.
- Human needs and conservation can conflict, so management needs compromise, monitoring and enforcement.
Who reaches the conclusion
Climate change is controversial, so ask who produced a claim, who funded it and whether it was peer reviewed.
Climate change is a controversial issue because the actions needed, and who pays, affect jobs, industries and lifestyles. Conclusions can depend on who is reaching them.
To judge a claim ask who produced it, who funded it, whether it was peer reviewed, whether the data are published and repeatable, and whether other independent studies agree.
A conclusion is not wrong simply because of its source, but the source is a reason to check the evidence more carefully.
- 1
Who produced it?
- 2
Who funded it?
a vested interest is a reason to check the evidence
- 3
Was it peer reviewed?
- 4
Are the data published and repeatable?
- 5
Do independent studies agree?
Industry, such as fossil fuels
- A vested interest, so may emphasise some data and not others
Campaigning groups
- May stress the worst predictions
Governments
- May be influenced by politics and public opinion
A report on climate was funded by an oil company. What should you say?
The carbon cycle and reducing CO₂
Photosynthesis removes carbon dioxide and stores carbon in sinks, so protecting sinks and burning less fossil fuel reduces atmospheric carbon dioxide.
In the carbon cycle, photosynthesis removes carbon dioxide from the atmosphere and stores carbon in organic compounds. Respiration, decomposition and combustion return it. Carbon is held in stores (sinks) such as forests, peat bogs, soils, oceans and fossil fuels.
Ways to reduce atmospheric carbon dioxide:
- burn less fossil fuel (renewables, biofuels)
- stop deforestation and replant forests
- protect peat bogs and wetlands, where decay is slow and carbon stays locked in
- use timber in long-lasting products
- capture carbon dioxide from power stations and store it
- 1
Photosynthesis
removes carbon dioxide from the atmosphere
- 2
Organic compounds
carbon stored in forests, peat bogs and soils
- 3
Respiration, decomposition, combustion
return carbon dioxide to the atmosphere
Why does protecting peat bogs help reduce atmospheric carbon dioxide?
Reforestation
Growing trees store carbon in wood, making the forest a carbon sink, until it matures and uptake balances release.
Reforestation is replanting trees on land that was forest. Growing trees take in carbon dioxide by photosynthesis and store carbon in wood, so the forest is a carbon sink. Forests also give habitats, reduce soil erosion and regulate water flow.
Planting helps conservation most when native species are used, as they support more wildlife than one fast-growing species.
Conflict: replanting uses land that could be farmed, so people may lose income.
- 1
Trees grow
taking in carbon dioxide by photosynthesis
- 2
Carbon is stored
in wood, so the forest is a carbon sink
- 3
Forest matures
uptake is roughly balanced by respiration and decay
- 4
Carbon is kept
only while trees are not removed or burned
Why does a mature forest stop taking in more carbon overall?
Sustainable resources
A sustainable resource is used at a rate that leaves it available in future, so felled trees are replaced and habitats kept.
A sustainable resource is used at a rate that does not prevent it being available in future.
For timber this means replacing felled trees, selective felling instead of clear-felling, and replanting with native species so forest cover, habitats and the carbon store are maintained. Timber in buildings and furniture keeps carbon locked up.
Management lets human needs (timber, jobs, fuel) be met while conserving biodiversity, and needs monitoring and enforcement to stop illegal or excessive felling.
- 1
Fell selected trees
selective felling, not clear-felling
- 2
Replant native species
habitats and carbon store kept
- 3
Trees regrow
- 4
Monitor and enforce
stops illegal or excessive felling
Then back to step 1
| Selective felling | Clear-felling | |
|---|---|---|
| What happens | Removes only some trees | Removes all trees in an area |
| Effect | Habitats and forest cover maintained | Habitats and forest cover lost |
Selective felling
- What happens:
- Removes only some trees
- Effect:
- Habitats and forest cover maintained
Clear-felling
- What happens:
- Removes all trees in an area
- Effect:
- Habitats and forest cover lost
Why is selective felling more sustainable than clear-felling?
Biofuels
Biofuels are carbon neutral in principle, because the crop absorbs as much carbon dioxide as burning releases, but production uses fossil fuels.
Biofuels are made from recently grown biological material, such as bioethanol from sugar cane or maize and biodiesel from oil palm or rapeseed.
In principle a biofuel is carbon neutral: the carbon dioxide released when burned is balanced by what the crop took in as it grew. In practice, fossil fuels are used to make fertiliser, run machinery and transport, so they are not wholly carbon neutral.
Using waste material or already cleared land is more sustainable.
- 1
Crop grows
takes in carbon dioxide by photosynthesis
- 2
Made into fuel
for example bioethanol or biodiesel
- 3
Fuel is burned
releases carbon dioxide
- 4
New crop grown
takes the carbon dioxide back in
Then back to step 1
Advantages
- Renewable
- Reduce use of fossil fuels
- Income for farmers
Disadvantages
- Crops compete with food production
- Clearing forest or peatland destroys habitats and releases stored carbon
- Fossil fuels used in production and transport
Why is a biofuel only carbon neutral "in principle"?
Human needs and conservation
Land wanted for both human needs and conservation causes conflict, so effective management finds a compromise and keeps it monitored.
Human needs include food, fuel, timber, income and jobs. Conservation protects species, habitats and carbon stores. These conflict when land is wanted for both.
Effective management finds a compromise: reforestation of degraded land, sustainable timber production with replanting, biofuel crops on cleared land and from waste, and involving local communities.
Evaluate schemes by weighing the benefits for people, biodiversity and carbon. Long-term success depends on enforcement and monitoring.
- 1
Human needs
food, fuel, timber, income, jobs
- 2
Conservation
species, habitats and carbon stores
- 3
Conflict over the same land
- 4
Compromise, monitored
replanting, biofuels, local communities involved
Human needs
- Food, fuel, timber, income, jobs
Conservation
- Protect species, habitats and carbon stores
Compromise
- Sustainable timber with replanting, biofuels from cleared land or waste, local communities involved
Suggest one compromise between timber production and conservation.
Try an exam question
Evaluate the use of biofuels to reduce atmospheric carbon dioxide.
[4 marks]
- [1]In principle biofuels are carbon neutral: the carbon dioxide released is balanced by that taken in by the crop.
- [1]They are renewable and reduce the use of fossil fuels.
- [1]Fossil fuels are used in production and transport, so they are not wholly carbon neutral.
- [1]Crops compete with food, and clearing forest or peatland destroys habitats and releases stored carbon; waste or cleared land is better.
That's the notes covered.
Carry on to the next subtopic.
Try a question
Why is planting native broadleaf trees more beneficial for conservation than planting a single non-native, fast-growing conifer?
1 mark, marked against the mark scheme
Why is planting native broadleaf trees more beneficial for conservation than planting a single non-native, fast-growing conifer?
1 mark, marked against the mark scheme