Studying health risk and perceptions of risk

Studying health risk and perceptions of risk

Spec 1.8–10 · Edexcel A-Level Biology A: Revision notes

Studying this course? Keep your progress in one place.

Key facts

  • Morbidity is the rate of illness and mortality the rate of death; compare populations using a rate such as per 100 000.
  • A correlation does not prove a causal relationship because a confounding variable may affect both.
  • Studies conflict because sample size, duration, methods and outcomes differ.
  • A sample must be representative; a larger sample is more reliable.
  • People often underestimate voluntary, long-term risks and overestimate dramatic, rare ones.

Analysing illness and mortality data

Convert counts to a rate per 100 000 so that populations of different sizes can be compared fairly.

Morbidity is the rate of illness and mortality is the rate of death. To compare populations of different sizes, express data as a rate such as deaths per 100 000 people.

Quote figures from the table, use comparisons (ratios or percentage differences), and consider age, sex and lifestyle.

0100200300400500600Town ATown BTownDeaths per 100 000
Illustrative: Town A has 2000 CHD deaths in 500 000 people; Town B has 600 in 100 000. Rates show Town B is at higher risk despite fewer deaths
  • Rate per 100 000number of casespopulation×100 000\dfrac{\text{number of cases}}{\text{population}} \times 100\,000

Worked example: rates

Town X has 48 CHD deaths in a population of 32 000. Town Y has 30 deaths in 12 500. Which town has the higher risk?

Why should deaths be converted to a rate before comparing populations?

Correlation and causation

A correlation shows a link between variables, but only a mechanism or a controlled experiment supports a causal relationship.

A correlation is a link between two variables. A causal relationship means a change in one directly produces the change in the other.

A confounding variable may affect both. For example, dog owners may have lower CHD death rates because they walk more, not because they own a dog.

Causation is more convincing with a plausible mechanism, a dose-response pattern, consistent results from several studies, and a trial in which only one variable is changed.

  1. 1

    Observation

    dog owners have lower CHD death rates

  2. 2

    Possible confounding variable

    dog owners also walk more, so take more exercise

  3. 3

    Exercise lowers CHD risk

    it may be the real cause of the lower rate

  4. 4

    So the link may not be causal

    a mechanism or controlled experiment is needed

A confounding variable can explain a correlation without causation

Correlation

  • A statistical link between two variables
  • Does not show cause

Causal relationship

  • A change in one directly produces a change in the other
  • Needs a mechanism or a controlled experiment

A study finds that dog owners have fewer CHD deaths. What is the best explanation?

Conflicting evidence

Studies differ in sample size, population, duration, method and outcome, so one study is rarely conclusive.

Studies on health risk sometimes conflict. Possible reasons include different sample sizes and populations, different durations, different methods of measuring diet or lifestyle, and different outcomes (CHD events or a risk factor such as LDL cholesterol).

To judge conflicting evidence, compare sample size, duration, controls and the quality of the measurement.

  1. 1

    Different samples and populations

    size, age, country, lifestyle

  2. 2

    Different methods

    duration, how diet or lifestyle is measured

  3. 3

    Different outcomes

    CHD events or a risk factor such as LDL cholesterol

  4. 4

    Conflicting results

    so one study is rarely conclusive

Why two studies on the same risk can disagree
  • One studyrarely conclusive
  • Several large, well-controlled studiesmore convincing weight of evidence

Why might two studies of the same risk factor give conflicting results?

Evaluating the design of risk studies

A good study uses a representative sample, a large size, controlled variables and reliable measurements.

Health risk studies include cohort studies (a group followed over time), case-control studies (people with a disease compared with people without) and controlled trials.

Control confounding variables or match groups for validity. Repeat readings, calculate means and use statistical tests for reliability. Self-reported data, such as diet questionnaires, may be inaccurate.

  1. 1

    Recruit a representative group

    large, without the disease at the start

  2. 2

    Follow them over time

    control or match confounding variables

  3. 3

    Record who develops the disease

    use reliable, repeated measurements

  4. 4

    Compare rates by exposure

    for example smokers and non-smokers

A cohort study follows a group forward in time

Good design

Sample:
Representative: random, covering all ages, sexes and lifestyles
Size:
Large, so chance and anomalies matter less
Measurement:
Controlled and repeated

Weak design

Sample:
Biased: volunteers from one group, such as a gym
Size:
Small, so chance has more effect
Measurement:
Self-reported, may be inaccurate

Which sample would be biased?

Perceptions of risk

People often underestimate voluntary, long-term risks and overestimate dramatic, rare ones they cannot control.

A person's perception of risk often differs from the actual risk.

Underestimating (for example CHD): voluntary risks feel under personal control, effects are long-term, and optimism bias says 'it will not happen to me'.

Overestimating (for example flying): dramatic, rare events get heavy media coverage, and people fear risks they cannot control.

Poor perception affects lifestyle choices, so public health messages need clear data.

  1. 1

    Actual risk

    measured from data such as mortality rates

  2. 2

    Perception is shaped by

    control, timescale, drama and optimism bias

  3. 3

    Common errors

    underestimating CHD; overestimating dramatic, rare events

Why perceived risk can differ from actual risk

Underestimated risk

Example:
CHD from smoking and diet
Why:
Voluntary, long-term, optimism bias

Overestimated risk

Example:
Violent crime or flying
Why:
Dramatic, rare events with heavy media coverage; risks outside control

What is optimism bias?

Try an exam question

A study of risk factors for coronary heart disease recruited only volunteers from a local gym. Evaluate the sample used.

[4 marks]

That's the notes covered.

Carry on to the next subtopic.

Try a question

Which statement is best supported by these data?

1 mark, marked against the mark scheme

Revision notes