Climate change: causes and evidence
Studying this course? Keep your progress in one place.
Key facts
- Ice cores, direct measurements, pollen in peat bogs and tree rings give evidence of past and present climate.
- Ice-core air bubbles show carbon dioxide stayed at about 180 to 280 ppm for 800 000 years; it is now over 420 ppm.
- Pollen and tree rings are indirect (proxy) evidence with limitations.
- A correlation does not prove causation; a mechanism and independent evidence do.
- Greenhouse gases absorb infrared radiation and re-radiate some back to the surface.
- Anthropogenic carbon dioxide and methane have raised the greenhouse effect.
Records of carbon dioxide and temperature
Ice cores give past carbon dioxide levels, while direct measurements and thermometers show the recent rise in carbon dioxide and temperature.
Evidence comes from direct records and indirect (proxy) evidence.
Ice cores are drilled from polar ice. Each year’s snow forms a layer, so layer counting gives the age. Air bubbles trapped in the ice are samples of the past atmosphere; they show carbon dioxide stayed between about 180 and 280 ppm for 800 000 years.
Direct measurements of carbon dioxide began in 1958 at Mauna Loa, Hawaii (316 ppm in 1959, over 420 ppm today). Thermometer records cover about 170 years and show a rise of about 1.1 °C since 1850.
Which evidence gives the carbon dioxide concentration from before 1958?
Pollen in peat bogs
Pollen preserved in peat layers shows which species grew at each time, so the climate is inferred from them.
Peat forms in waterlogged, acidic, low-oxygen bogs where decomposers are inhibited, so plant remains and pollen are preserved in layers. The outer wall of pollen is very resistant and each species has a distinctive shape.
Cold-tolerant birch and pine suggest a cold period; warmth-loving oak and hazel suggest a warm one.
Limitations: vegetation depends on rainfall, soil and human activity as well as temperature; species make different amounts of pollen; pollen can blow in from afar.
- 1
Take a core
from a peat bog, with layers of different ages
- 2
Identify and count
pollen grains in each layer under a microscope
- 3
Date the layers
by radiocarbon dating or by depth
- 4
Infer the climate
from the proportions of species present
Why is pollen analysis described as indirect evidence?
Dendrochronology
Tree rings record growth year by year, and cross-dating timbers builds a long record from which past conditions are inferred.
Dendrochronology is the study of tree rings. In temperate climates a tree adds one ring each year as the cambium lays down new xylem. In a favourable year (warm, with enough water) the ring is wide; in a poor year it is narrow.
Patterns of wide and narrow rings are matched between living trees and older timbers such as building beams and bog oaks (cross-dating), giving a continuous record covering thousands of years.
Limitation: ring width is also affected by rainfall, light, nutrients, pests and competition.
- 1
Measure ring widths
in living trees
- 2
Cross-date
match wide and narrow patterns with older timbers
- 3
Build a record
a continuous sequence covering thousands of years
- 4
Compare
ring widths with known climate records to infer past conditions
A tree has a very narrow ring for one year. What can you say?
Correlation and causation
A correlation shows an association only; a causal link needs a plausible mechanism and independent lines of evidence.
A correlation is a relationship between two variables, for example carbon dioxide concentration and global temperature. A causal relationship means a change in one directly produces the change in the other.
A correlation alone does not prove causation: a third factor may affect both, or the link may be chance.
Evidence for causation comes from a plausible mechanism (here, the greenhouse effect), repeated findings from independent lines of evidence, and a link in the right time order.
- 1
State the correlation
carbon dioxide and temperature rise together
- 2
Say it does not prove cause
a third factor or chance could explain it
- 3
Add the extra evidence
a mechanism and independent lines of evidence
Which is evidence that supports a causal link, rather than only a correlation?
The greenhouse effect
Greenhouse gases absorb infrared radiation from the surface and re-radiate some back, so less heat escapes to space.
Short-wavelength radiation from the Sun passes through the atmosphere and is absorbed by the Earth’s surface. The warm surface re-emits longer-wavelength infrared radiation.
Greenhouse gases, mainly water vapour, carbon dioxide and methane, absorb infrared radiation and re-radiate some back to the surface. Less heat escapes, so the lower atmosphere is warmer than it would be.
The natural effect keeps Earth habitable. The enhanced greenhouse effect is when human activity raises the concentrations of these gases, so more infrared is trapped.
- 1
Sun’s radiation
short-wavelength radiation passes through the atmosphere
- 2
Surface absorbs
and warms
- 3
Infrared re-emitted
longer-wavelength radiation leaves the surface
- 4
Greenhouse gases
absorb it and re-radiate some back, so less escapes to space
What is the enhanced greenhouse effect?
Anthropogenic causes
Burning fossil fuels and deforestation raise carbon dioxide; farming animals, rice paddies, landfill and gas leaks raise methane.
Anthropogenic means caused by humans.
- Carbon dioxide: burning coal, oil and gas releases carbon stored for millions of years. Deforestation reduces photosynthesis, so less is removed, and burning or decay of felled trees releases it.
- Methane: made by anaerobic microbes in the guts of cattle and sheep, in flooded rice paddies, in landfill sites, and leaked from natural gas extraction. Thawing permafrost can release more.
Carbon dioxide has risen from about 280 ppm before 1850 to over 420 ppm.
| Carbon dioxide | Methane | |
|---|---|---|
| Concentration | Higher | Far lower |
| Time in atmosphere | Longer | Shorter |
| Absorption per molecule | Weaker | Stronger |
Carbon dioxide
- Concentration:
- Higher
- Time in atmosphere:
- Longer
- Absorption per molecule:
- Weaker
Methane
- Concentration:
- Far lower
- Time in atmosphere:
- Shorter
- Absorption per molecule:
- Stronger
Name two human activities that release methane.
Try an exam question
Explain how ice cores and pollen provide evidence of past climate, and give one limitation of each.
[4 marks]
- [1]Air bubbles in ice cores are samples of the past atmosphere, showing carbon dioxide concentration.
- [1]Limitation of ice cores: for example the age depends on counting layers, or they only sample polar regions.
- [1]Pollen preserved in peat layers shows which species were present, so climate is inferred.
- [1]Limitation of pollen: vegetation also depends on rainfall, soil and human activity, or pollen may blow in from afar.
That's the notes covered.
Carry on to the next subtopic.
Try a question
Why are pollen grains so well preserved in the layers of a peat bog?
1 mark, marked against the mark scheme
Why are pollen grains so well preserved in the layers of a peat bog?
1 mark, marked against the mark scheme