Exercise, medical technology and ethics
Studying this course? Keep your progress in one place.
Key facts
- Too little exercise is linked to obesity, cardiovascular disease and type 2 diabetes; too much to joint damage and a suppressed immune system.
- A correlation does not prove causation because confounding variables may differ between groups.
- Keyhole surgery causes less tissue damage and faster recovery but needs costly equipment and skilled surgeons.
- Prostheses restore function but can wear, loosen or become infected.
- Anabolic steroids and EPO raise performance; ethical arguments are fairness, harm and autonomy.
Too little and too much exercise
Regular moderate exercise reduces disease risk; too little raises it, and extreme exercise can cause joint damage and infections.
A lack of exercise is linked to:
- Obesity: less energy is used, so excess energy is stored as fat.
- Cardiovascular disease (CVD): raised blood pressure and cholesterol, and atherosclerosis.
- Type 2 diabetes: body cells become less sensitive to insulin.
Excessive, intense or repeated exercise can also harm: wear and tear on joints (damaged cartilage can lead to osteoarthritis), and suppression of the immune system, with more infections in the following weeks.
Moderate regular exercise is generally beneficial.
| Too little exercise | Too much exercise | |
|---|---|---|
| Risk 1 | Obesity | Joint wear and tear, osteoarthritis |
| Risk 2 | Cardiovascular disease | Immune system suppressed |
| Risk 3 | Type 2 diabetes | More infections |
Too little exercise
- Risk 1:
- Obesity
- Risk 2:
- Cardiovascular disease
- Risk 3:
- Type 2 diabetes
Too much exercise
- Risk 1:
- Joint wear and tear, osteoarthritis
- Risk 2:
- Immune system suppressed
- Risk 3:
- More infections
How does lack of exercise contribute to type 2 diabetes?
Correlation and causation
A correlation shows an association; supporting causation needs controlled variables, large repeated studies and a mechanism.
A correlation is a relationship between two variables. A causal relationship means a change in one causes the change in the other. Data often come from large cohort studies comparing activity with disease rates.
A correlation does not prove causation, because confounding variables (such as diet or age) may differ between groups.
To support causation: control or match confounding variables, use large samples, repeat studies, use controlled trials, and identify a plausible mechanism.
- 1
Correlation found
activity and disease rates are linked
- 2
Confounders considered
diet, age and other differences controlled or matched
- 3
Large, repeated studies
and controlled trials
- 4
Mechanism identified
a plausible way one causes the other
Worked example
5.0% of an active group develop a disease, and an inactive group is 2.4 times more likely to develop it. What percentage of the inactive group develop the disease?
- 1
Multiply the active group’s percentage by the factor.
- 2
Why does a correlation not prove causation?
Keyhole surgery
A camera and thin instruments pass through small incisions, giving less damage and faster recovery, but needing costly equipment and skilled surgeons.
In keyhole surgery (arthroscopy), a camera (arthroscope) and thin instruments are inserted through small incisions. The surgeon views the joint on a screen.
- 1
Small incisions
Much less tissue is cut than in open surgery.
- 2
Camera and thin instruments inserted
The arthroscope goes into the joint.
- 3
Surgeon views a screen
Repairs are made using the instruments.
- 4
Faster recovery
Less damage and a shorter stay, so athletes return sooner.
Advantages
- Less tissue damage
- Less blood loss and scarring
- Lower risk of infection
- Shorter hospital stay and faster recovery, so athletes return to sport sooner
Disadvantages
- Costly equipment
- Highly trained surgeons needed
- Not suitable for every injury
Why is recovery faster after keyhole surgery?
Prostheses
A prosthesis is an artificial replacement for a body part that restores function, though it has limitations.
A prosthesis is an artificial replacement for a body part, for example replacement hip and knee joints, and carbon-fibre running blades for people with amputations.
They restore function, so people with injuries and disabilities can take part in sport and other activities.
Limitations: they can wear, loosen or become infected; they are costly and need replacing; and there are debates over whether advanced prostheses give an unfair advantage.
- 1
Injury or amputation
A joint or limb is damaged or missing.
- 2
Prosthesis fitted
For example a replacement hip or a carbon-fibre running blade.
- 3
Function restored
The person can take part in sport and other activities.
- 4
Limitations
Wear, loosening, infection, cost and the unfair advantage debate.
Benefits
- Restore function
- Allow sport and other activities
Limitations
- Can wear, loosen or become infected
- Costly and need replacing
- Possible unfair advantage
Give one benefit and one limitation of prostheses.
Performance-enhancing substances
Anabolic steroids and EPO improve performance, and a strong answer weighs fairness, harm and autonomy before reaching a justified conclusion.
Anabolic steroids increase muscle growth. EPO increases red blood cell production, so more oxygen is delivered to the muscles.
A strong answer weighs the arguments and gives a justified conclusion. Name the ethical position you are using (fairness, harm, autonomy).
- 1
EPO taken
It increases red blood cell production.
- 2
More red blood cells
More haemoglobin to carry oxygen.
- 3
More oxygen delivered
The muscles receive more oxygen.
- 4
Better performance
More aerobic respiration, so endurance improves. Weigh fairness, harm and autonomy.
Against
- Unfair advantage (cheating)
- Health risks such as heart disease, liver damage and clotting
- Pressure on clean athletes and young people
- Role-model effect
For
- If all are allowed under medical supervision, the playing field is level and risks are lower
- Autonomy: informed adults can choose
How does EPO improve performance?
Try an exam question
Evaluate the ethical arguments for and against allowing athletes to use performance-enhancing substances.
[4 marks]
- [1]Against: it is an unfair advantage and is cheating.
- [1]Against: health risks such as heart disease, liver damage and clotting.
- [1]For: if all are allowed under medical supervision the playing field is level and risks are lower, and informed adults can choose (autonomy).
- [1]A justified conclusion weighing fairness, harm and autonomy.
That's the notes covered.
Carry on to the next subtopic.
Try a question
What percentage of the less active group would be expected to develop type 2 diabetes?
1 mark, marked against the mark scheme
What percentage of the less active group would be expected to develop type 2 diabetes?
1 mark, marked against the mark scheme