Exercise, medical technology and ethics

Exercise, medical technology and ethics

Spec 7.13–15 · Edexcel A-Level Biology A: Revision notes

Studying this course? Keep your progress in one place.

Key facts

  • Too little exercise is linked to obesity, cardiovascular disease and type 2 diabetes; too much to joint damage and a suppressed immune system.
  • A correlation does not prove causation because confounding variables may differ between groups.
  • Keyhole surgery causes less tissue damage and faster recovery but needs costly equipment and skilled surgeons.
  • Prostheses restore function but can wear, loosen or become infected.
  • Anabolic steroids and EPO raise performance; ethical arguments are fairness, harm and autonomy.

Too little and too much exercise

Regular moderate exercise reduces disease risk; too little raises it, and extreme exercise can cause joint damage and infections.

A lack of exercise is linked to:

  • Obesity: less energy is used, so excess energy is stored as fat.
  • Cardiovascular disease (CVD): raised blood pressure and cholesterol, and atherosclerosis.
  • Type 2 diabetes: body cells become less sensitive to insulin.

Excessive, intense or repeated exercise can also harm: wear and tear on joints (damaged cartilage can lead to osteoarthritis), and suppression of the immune system, with more infections in the following weeks.

Moderate regular exercise is generally beneficial.

12345678910246810xyModerate exerciseHealth risk
Illustrative only: health risk is higher with too little and with too much exercise, and lowest with moderate regular exercise.

Too little exercise

Risk 1:
Obesity
Risk 2:
Cardiovascular disease
Risk 3:
Type 2 diabetes

Too much exercise

Risk 1:
Joint wear and tear, osteoarthritis
Risk 2:
Immune system suppressed
Risk 3:
More infections

How does lack of exercise contribute to type 2 diabetes?

Correlation and causation

A correlation shows an association; supporting causation needs controlled variables, large repeated studies and a mechanism.

A correlation is a relationship between two variables. A causal relationship means a change in one causes the change in the other. Data often come from large cohort studies comparing activity with disease rates.

A correlation does not prove causation, because confounding variables (such as diet or age) may differ between groups.

To support causation: control or match confounding variables, use large samples, repeat studies, use controlled trials, and identify a plausible mechanism.

  1. 1

    Correlation found

    activity and disease rates are linked

  2. 2

    Confounders considered

    diet, age and other differences controlled or matched

  3. 3

    Large, repeated studies

    and controlled trials

  4. 4

    Mechanism identified

    a plausible way one causes the other

Moving from correlation to cause

Worked example

5.0% of an active group develop a disease, and an inactive group is 2.4 times more likely to develop it. What percentage of the inactive group develop the disease?

Why does a correlation not prove causation?

Keyhole surgery

A camera and thin instruments pass through small incisions, giving less damage and faster recovery, but needing costly equipment and skilled surgeons.

In keyhole surgery (arthroscopy), a camera (arthroscope) and thin instruments are inserted through small incisions. The surgeon views the joint on a screen.

  1. 1

    Small incisions

    Much less tissue is cut than in open surgery.

  2. 2

    Camera and thin instruments inserted

    The arthroscope goes into the joint.

  3. 3

    Surgeon views a screen

    Repairs are made using the instruments.

  4. 4

    Faster recovery

    Less damage and a shorter stay, so athletes return sooner.

Keyhole surgery (arthroscopy)

Advantages

  • Less tissue damage
  • Less blood loss and scarring
  • Lower risk of infection
  • Shorter hospital stay and faster recovery, so athletes return to sport sooner

Disadvantages

  • Costly equipment
  • Highly trained surgeons needed
  • Not suitable for every injury

Why is recovery faster after keyhole surgery?

Prostheses

A prosthesis is an artificial replacement for a body part that restores function, though it has limitations.

A prosthesis is an artificial replacement for a body part, for example replacement hip and knee joints, and carbon-fibre running blades for people with amputations.

They restore function, so people with injuries and disabilities can take part in sport and other activities.

Limitations: they can wear, loosen or become infected; they are costly and need replacing; and there are debates over whether advanced prostheses give an unfair advantage.

  1. 1

    Injury or amputation

    A joint or limb is damaged or missing.

  2. 2

    Prosthesis fitted

    For example a replacement hip or a carbon-fibre running blade.

  3. 3

    Function restored

    The person can take part in sport and other activities.

  4. 4

    Limitations

    Wear, loosening, infection, cost and the unfair advantage debate.

What a prosthesis does and where it falls short

Benefits

  • Restore function
  • Allow sport and other activities

Limitations

  • Can wear, loosen or become infected
  • Costly and need replacing
  • Possible unfair advantage

Give one benefit and one limitation of prostheses.

Performance-enhancing substances

Anabolic steroids and EPO improve performance, and a strong answer weighs fairness, harm and autonomy before reaching a justified conclusion.

Anabolic steroids increase muscle growth. EPO increases red blood cell production, so more oxygen is delivered to the muscles.

A strong answer weighs the arguments and gives a justified conclusion. Name the ethical position you are using (fairness, harm, autonomy).

  1. 1

    EPO taken

    It increases red blood cell production.

  2. 2

    More red blood cells

    More haemoglobin to carry oxygen.

  3. 3

    More oxygen delivered

    The muscles receive more oxygen.

  4. 4

    Better performance

    More aerobic respiration, so endurance improves. Weigh fairness, harm and autonomy.

How EPO can improve performance

Against

  • Unfair advantage (cheating)
  • Health risks such as heart disease, liver damage and clotting
  • Pressure on clean athletes and young people
  • Role-model effect

For

  • If all are allowed under medical supervision, the playing field is level and risks are lower
  • Autonomy: informed adults can choose

How does EPO improve performance?

Try an exam question

Evaluate the ethical arguments for and against allowing athletes to use performance-enhancing substances.

[4 marks]

That's the notes covered.

Carry on to the next subtopic.

Try a question

What percentage of the less active group would be expected to develop type 2 diabetes?

1 mark, marked against the mark scheme

Revision notes