Brain development, nature and nurture

Brain development, nature and nurture

Spec 8.10 · Edexcel A-Level Biology A: Revision notes

Studying this course? Keep your progress in one place.

Key facts

  • Nature is the effect of genes; nurture is the effect of environment and experience.
  • The visual cortex needs input from both eyes during the critical period to develop normally.
  • Connections with regular input strengthen; connections with no input are not formed or are lost.
  • Hubel and Wiesel closed one eye of kittens: the reopened eye was functionally blind, though retina and optic nerve were normal.
  • Animal research is useful but limited, and raises ethical issues.

The critical period

During the critical period the visual cortex needs input from both eyes to form the connections for depth perception and sharp vision.

In the first weeks and months of life, neurones in the visual cortex form connections with the eyes. Neurones with regular input form stronger synapses; connections with no input are not formed or are lost.

After the critical period the connections are largely fixed and much harder to change.

  1. 1

    Stimulation

    input from both eyes arrives

  2. 2

    Connections strengthen

    neurones with regular input form stronger synapses

  3. 3

    Unused lost

    connections with no input not formed or lost

  4. 4

    Result

    depth perception and sharp vision

Visual cortex development in the critical period

Why can a child with a cataract need early treatment?

Hubel and Wiesel

Kittens deprived of input to one eye in the critical period became functionally blind in that eye, though the eye itself was normal.

They sutured one eye of kittens (later monkeys) shut for the first weeks or months, then reopened it and recorded neurone activity in the visual cortex.

Almost no cortical neurones responded to the closed eye; most responded to the open eye. The same closure in adult animals had no such effect. The idea explains why children with a cataract or squint need early treatment.

  1. 1

    Suture

    close one eye of a kitten for weeks or months

  2. 2

    Reopen

    open the eye again

  3. 3

    Record

    measure neurone activity in the visual cortex

  4. 4

    Result

    almost no response to the closed eye; retina and optic nerve normal

Hubel and Wiesel: monocular deprivation

The same closure in adult animals had no such effect. What does this show?

Animal models

Animal brains have similar structure and function, and controlled experiments are possible that would be unacceptable on humans.

Animals act as models of the human brain, and results help us understand human development and improve treatment.

Limits: animal brains are not identical to human brains, so results may not transfer exactly, and the experiments raise ethical issues.

  1. 1

    Choose an animal

    with a similar brain structure and function

  2. 2

    Controlled experiment

    vary one factor and measure brain development

  3. 3

    Apply to humans

    results help explain development and improve treatment

  4. 4

    Check the limits

    brains are not identical and there are ethical issues

How animal models are used, and where they fall short.

Advantages

  • Similar brain structure and function
  • Controlled experiments

Limitations

  • Brains not identical
  • Ethical issues

Give one reason why results from kittens may not apply fully to humans.

Nature and nurture

Newborn babies, animal experiments, brain damage, twins and cross-cultural studies each give evidence.

Nature is the effect of genes and nurture the effect of environment and experience.

Identical twins share all genes, non-identical about half. If identical twins are more alike, genes influence the trait.

  1. 1

    Compare twin pairs

    identical twins share all genes; non-identical share about half

  2. 2

    Measure the trait

    in each pair, such as a behaviour or ability

  3. 3

    Identical more alike?

    then genes (nature) influence the trait

  4. 4

    Reared apart?

    similarity despite different environments supports genes

Reasoning from twin studies.

Twin studies

  • Identical more alike than non-identical: genes
  • Identical twins reared apart help separate genes from environment

Cross-cultural studies

  • Found in all cultures: innate
  • Differs between cultures: learned

Identical twins are much more alike than non-identical twins for a trait. What does this suggest?

Ethics of animal research

Utilitarian and animal rights standpoints reach different views, and a good answer applies each to the research.

The utilitarian standpoint says the right action gives the greatest good for the greatest number, so human benefit may outweigh animal suffering, but harm must be minimised.

The animal rights standpoint says animals are sentient, cannot consent and have a right not to be harmed.

  1. 1

    Identify harm and benefit

    what suffering to animals, what gain for humans

  2. 2

    Utilitarian view

    is the greatest good achieved, with harm minimised?

  3. 3

    Animal rights view

    animals are sentient and cannot consent, so harm is wrong

  4. 4

    Reach a judgement

    justify it using the standpoints

Applying each standpoint to a piece of animal research.

Utilitarian

  • Greatest good for the greatest number
  • Human benefit may outweigh animal suffering
  • Harm must be minimised

Animal rights

  • Animals are sentient
  • Cannot give consent
  • Right not to be harmed

Which standpoint says animals must not be used as a means to an end?

Try an exam question

Describe the experiment by Hubel and Wiesel on kittens and explain what it shows about brain development.

[4 marks]

That's the notes covered.

Carry on to the next subtopic.

Try a question

Which statement best explains why the adult cats lost no vision?

1 mark, marked against the mark scheme

Revision notes