Genetic screening and ethical issues

Genetic screening and ethical issues

Spec 2.15–16 · Edexcel A-Level Biology A: Revision notes

Studying this course? Keep your progress in one place.

Key facts

  • Genetic screening tests for particular alleles or chromosome abnormalities; it gives information but does not treat a disorder.
  • If both parents are carriers, each child has a 1 in 4 chance of the disorder and a 1 in 2 chance of being a carrier.
  • PGD tests embryos made by IVF at the eight-cell stage before they are implanted.
  • Amniocentesis (from about 15 weeks) and CVS (from about 11 weeks) test the fetus and carry a miscarriage risk of roughly 1%.
  • Ethical arguments include sanctity of life, utilitarian, autonomy, disability rights and the slippery slope.

What is genetic screening?

Genetic screening tests people, embryos or fetuses for a particular allele or chromosome abnormality.

Genetic screening is testing for the presence of a particular allele or chromosome abnormality. DNA is usually extracted from a blood sample, cheek swab, or cells from an embryo or fetus, and tested for the allele.

It gives information about alleles or chromosomes; it does not treat or cure a disorder.

  1. 1

    Carrier screening

    adults, before having children

  2. 2

    PGD

    embryos made by IVF, before placing in the uterus

  3. 3

    Prenatal testing

    the fetus, during pregnancy

Genetic screening can be done at three points.

Carrier screening

Who or what is tested:
Adults
When:
Before having children

PGD

Who or what is tested:
Embryos made by IVF
When:
Before the embryo is placed in the uterus

Prenatal testing

Who or what is tested:
Fetus
When:
During pregnancy

Which of these is a use of genetic screening?

Identifying carriers

Carrier screening shows whether a person could pass on a recessive allele; if both partners are carriers each child has a 1 in 4 chance of the disorder.

A carrier is a heterozygote with one copy of a recessive allele and no symptoms. Carrier screening, for example for the CF allele, shows whether a person could pass it on.

Genetic counselling explains the risks and the options: PGD, prenatal testing, adoption, or deciding not to have children.

01020304050aa (affected)Aa (carrier)AA (unaffected)Child's genotypeChance (%)
Chance of each genotype for a child when both parents are carriers (Aa × Aa): 1 in 4, 1 in 2 and 1 in 4.

Homozygous recessive

Chance for each child:
1 in 4
Phenotype:
Has the disorder

Heterozygous

Chance for each child:
1 in 2
Phenotype:
Carrier, no symptoms

Homozygous dominant

Chance for each child:
1 in 4
Phenotype:
Unaffected, not a carrier

Two parents are both carriers of cystic fibrosis. What is the chance that a child is a carrier but unaffected?

Pre-implantation genetic diagnosis (PGD)

PGD tests embryos made by IVF for a faulty allele, so only unaffected embryos are implanted.

PGD is used for couples with a known risk of passing on a serious genetic disorder.

Embryos are made by IVF. At the eight-cell stage, one or two cells are removed from each embryo. These cells are totipotent and unspecialised, so removing them does not stop the embryo developing.

  1. 1

    IVF

    eggs are fertilised outside the body to make embryos

  2. 2

    Eight-cell stage

    one or two cells are removed from each embryo

  3. 3

    DNA test

    the cells are tested for the faulty allele

  4. 4

    Selection

    only unaffected embryos are chosen

  5. 5

    Implantation

    chosen embryos are placed in the uterus

The PGD process.

Advantages

  • No pregnancy has to be terminated

Disadvantages

  • IVF is expensive, involves hormone treatment and often fails
  • Affected embryos are discarded

Why can cells be removed from an eight-cell embryo without stopping its development?

Prenatal testing

Amniocentesis tests amniotic fluid from about 15 weeks, and CVS tests placental tissue from about 11 weeks; both carry a miscarriage risk.

Amniocentesis: a needle passed through the abdomen takes amniotic fluid containing fetal cells, whose DNA or chromosomes are analysed.

Chorionic villus sampling (CVS): a sample of tissue from the chorion (placenta) is taken, using a needle or a tube through the cervix. The cells have the fetus's genotype.

Prenatal tests do not treat the disorder: they give information.

  1. 11 weeks

    CVS from 11 weeks

    Tissue from the chorion (placenta); miscarriage risk about 1%.

  2. 15 weeks

    Amniocentesis from 15 wks

    Amniotic fluid with fetal cells; miscarriage risk about 1%.

Amniocentesis

Timing:
From about 15 weeks
Sample:
Amniotic fluid with fetal cells
Risk:
Miscarriage, roughly 1%

CVS

Timing:
From about 11 weeks
Sample:
Tissue from the chorion (placenta)
Risk:
Miscarriage, roughly 1%

What is the main advantage of CVS over amniocentesis?

Implications of prenatal screening

A positive result forces a difficult decision and a negative result gives reassurance but not certainty.

A positive result means the parents must decide whether to continue the pregnancy, which can cause great distress. A negative result gives reassurance, but no test is 100% accurate.

Other implications: waiting for results causes anxiety, the tests risk miscarriage, results may reveal unexpected information such as non-paternity, and parents might feel pressure toward termination or prepare early to care for a child with the condition.

  1. 1

    Prenatal test result

  2. 2

    Positive

    parents decide whether to continue the pregnancy; great distress possible

  3. 3

    Negative

    reassurance, but no test is 100% accurate

A prenatal test result has consequences either way.

Positive result

  • Decision whether to continue the pregnancy
  • Great distress possible

Negative result

  • Reassurance
  • But no test is 100% accurate

Give two implications of a prenatal test for the parents.

Social and ethical issues

Name a viewpoint and apply it: sanctity of life, utilitarian, autonomy, disability rights, slippery slope and social issues.

Examiners expect you to name a viewpoint and apply it.

Sanctity of life (often religious): human life begins at fertilisation. Utilitarian: choose the action giving the greatest overall good. Autonomy: parents may make informed decisions about their own reproduction.

In discussion questions, give at least two different viewpoints, show how they disagree, then reach a justified conclusion if asked.

  1. 1

    Name a viewpoint

    sanctity of life, utilitarian, autonomy…

  2. 2

    Apply it to the case

  3. 3

    Give a second, different viewpoint

  4. 4

    Show how they disagree

  5. 5

    Reach a justified conclusion

    if asked

How to answer an ethics question.

Idea

Sanctity of life:
Embryos have absolute value
Utilitarian:
Greatest good for most people
Autonomy:
Right to informed decisions about reproduction
Disability rights:
Screening may imply some lives are less valuable
Slippery slope:
PGD might extend to non-medical traits (designer babies)
Social issues:
Cost, unequal access, confidentiality, discrimination

Likely view

Sanctity of life:
Against discarding embryos or terminating
Utilitarian:
For: reduces suffering
Autonomy:
For: parents choose
Disability rights:
Concern
Slippery slope:
Concern
Social issues:
Concern

A couple argue that they have the right to choose which embryos are implanted. Which viewpoint is this?

Try an exam question

Discuss the ethical issues raised by pre-implantation genetic diagnosis (PGD).

[4 marks]

That's the notes covered.

Carry on to the next subtopic.

Try a question

What is the name of this type of genetic screening?

1 mark, marked against the mark scheme

Revision notes