Sustainability and conservation of species
Studying this course? Keep your progress in one place.
Key facts
- A sustainable process meets present needs without using up resources future generations need.
- Plant-based products use a renewable resource and absorb carbon dioxide as they grow; plastics from crude oil use a finite one.
- Starch (from α-glucose) can be made into bioplastics; evaluate both advantages and disadvantages.
- Zoos use captive breeding with a studbook, reintroduction, research and education.
- Seed banks store dried seeds at about −20 °C, keeping genetic diversity cheaply.
- Zoos and seed banks are ex situ; they back up in situ conservation in natural habitats.
Sustainable plant products
Plants are renewable and absorb carbon dioxide, so plant-based products use fewer finite resources and release less net carbon dioxide than oil-based plastics.
A process is sustainable if it meets present needs without using up resources that future generations will need.
Many plastics come from crude oil, which is finite, and can persist for hundreds of years.
Plants are renewable and absorb carbon dioxide in photosynthesis, so a plant-based product can have a lower net release of carbon dioxide. Plant fibres such as flax, hemp and jute (strong because of cellulose microfibrils and lignin) can replace synthetic fibres in rope, textiles, paper, packaging and composites, and are biodegradable.
- 1
Plants grow
A renewable resource
- 2
Absorb carbon dioxide
By photosynthesis
- 3
Made into products
Carbon is stored in plant material
- 4
Product biodegrades
Carbon dioxide is released again
Then back to step 1
| Plastic from crude oil | Plant-based product | |
|---|---|---|
| Resource | Finite | Renewable |
| Persistence | Hundreds of years | Biodegradable |
| Net carbon dioxide release | Higher | Lower |
Plastic from crude oil
- Resource:
- Finite
- Persistence:
- Hundreds of years
- Net carbon dioxide release:
- Higher
Plant-based product
- Resource:
- Renewable
- Persistence:
- Biodegradable
- Net carbon dioxide release:
- Lower
Why is a plant fibre rope more sustainable than a synthetic rope?
Starch and bioplastics
Starch from crops such as maize and potato can be processed into bioplastics that replace oil-based plastics, but they have drawbacks too.
Starch is a polymer of α-glucose made by plants as an energy store. Starch from maize and potato can be processed into bioplastics, for example thermoplastic starch, or polylactic acid made by fermenting the sugars. They are used for bags, packaging, cutlery and bottles. Plant fibres and starch can also be combined as composites.
The carbon in the plastic was taken from the air by the crop, so net carbon dioxide release is lower than for fossil fuel plastics.
When evaluating, give both sides, use the data and end with a justified judgement.
- 1
Grow the crop
maize or potato takes carbon dioxide from the air
- 2
Extract starch
a polymer of α-glucose
- 3
Process
make thermoplastic starch, or ferment the sugars to make polylactic acid
- 4
Use
bags, packaging, cutlery and bottles
Advantages
- Renewable raw material
- Less use of crude oil
- Lower net carbon dioxide emissions
- Many are biodegradable, so less litter
Disadvantages
- Crops need land, water, fertiliser and energy
- May compete with food or cause deforestation
- Some break down only in industrial composting
- Can contaminate plastic recycling; may cost more
Give one reason why a bioplastic may not be better for the environment than an oil-based plastic.
Zoos and captive breeding
Zoos conserve endangered species away from their natural habitat through captive breeding, reintroduction, research and education.
Zoos carry out ex situ conservation (away from the natural habitat):
- Captive breeding: animals breed in protected conditions. A studbook records parentage, and animals or sperm are exchanged between zoos to avoid inbreeding and maintain genetic diversity.
- Reintroduction: offspring are released into protected habitat. They must be prepared for the wild and checked for disease, and the cause of the decline dealt with.
- Research into diet, behaviour, breeding and disease.
- Education, which builds support and funding.
Limits: small populations risk inbreeding; space and cost limit the species held; captive animals may lose natural behaviours.
- 1
Breed in captivity
protected conditions, numbers rise
- 2
Manage the genes
studbook and exchange between zoos maintain genetic diversity
- 3
Prepare and check
prepare for the wild and check for disease
- 4
Release
into protected habitat, once the cause of decline is dealt with
Why is a studbook used in a captive breeding programme?
Seed banks
Seed banks store seeds from many individuals, dried and frozen so that metabolism is very slow and the seeds stay viable for decades.
A seed bank stores seeds of endangered and useful plants ex situ.
Seeds are collected from many individuals and populations to capture genetic diversity, dried to a low moisture content and stored at about −20 °C.
Low water content and low temperature make metabolism very slow, so germination and fungal growth are prevented and the seeds stay viable for decades.
- 1
Collect
seeds from many individuals and populations
- 2
Dry
to a low moisture content
- 3
Freeze
store at about −20 °C
- 4
Viable for decades
metabolism is very slow
Advantages
- Very many species stored in a small space at low cost
- Safe from habitat loss and disease
- Seeds can be germinated to reintroduce the species or for research
Limitations
- Some seeds (many tropical) cannot survive drying and freezing
- Viability must be tested and seeds regrown, which costs money
- Ecosystem and pollinators are not conserved; the cause of decline is not tackled
Why must seeds be dried before they are frozen in a seed bank?
Evaluating zoos and seed banks
Both are ex situ methods, with different strengths, and both work best as a back-up to in situ conservation.
When asked to evaluate, set out strengths and weaknesses and finish with a judgement supported by evidence.
Seed banks are cheaper and hold far more species, but cannot store every seed and do not conserve habitats. Zoos can protect charismatic species, educate and reintroduce, but conserve few species at high cost and small populations lose genetic diversity.
In situ conservation protects species in their natural habitat, for example in a nature reserve.
- 1
In situ first
Protect species in their habitat
- 2
Seed banks
Low cost, many plant species, but not every seed stores and habitats are not conserved
- 3
Zoos
Few species, high cost, but educate and reintroduce
- 4
Judgement
Both work best as a back-up to in situ conservation
| Seed bank | Zoo | |
|---|---|---|
| Species held | Many species | Few species |
| Cost | Low | High |
| Notes | Plants only | Animals; can educate and reintroduce |
Seed bank
- Species held:
- Many species
- Cost:
- Low
- Notes:
- Plants only
Zoo
- Species held:
- Few species
- Cost:
- High
- Notes:
- Animals; can educate and reintroduce
Which of these is an in situ conservation method?
Try an exam question
Evaluate the use of seed banks and zoos in conserving endangered species.
[4 marks]
- [1]Seed banks store many species cheaply in a small space and keep genetic diversity.
- [1]Some seeds cannot survive drying and freezing, and the habitat is not conserved.
- [1]Zoos can breed endangered animals, reintroduce them and educate the public, but conserve few species at high cost.
- [1]Small zoo populations risk inbreeding; both are best used as a back-up to in situ conservation.
That's the notes covered.
Carry on to the next subtopic.
Try a question
Which statement best explains why a bioplastic made from maize starch is more sustainable than polythene?
1 mark, marked against the mark scheme
Which statement best explains why a bioplastic made from maize starch is more sustainable than polythene?
1 mark, marked against the mark scheme