Antibiotics, resistance and infection control
Studying this course? Keep your progress in one place.
Key facts
- Hosts and pathogens are in an evolutionary race: defences act as selection pressures on pathogens.
- Bacteriostatic antibiotics stop reproduction; bactericidal antibiotics kill bacteria.
- Resistance arises by random mutation, then selection, and spreads by vertical transmission or plasmids.
- Misuse of antibiotics (viral infections, unnecessary broad-spectrum, incomplete courses) speeds resistance.
- Codes of practice govern prescribing and infection control in hospitals.
- Core practical: zones of inhibition; compare areas, not diameters.
The evolutionary race
Host defences act as selection pressures, so pathogens with evasion mutations survive and spread, driving an evolutionary race.
Hosts evolve defences such as phagocytosis, antibodies and memory cells. These act as selection pressures on pathogens. Pathogens with mutations that help them evade defences survive, reproduce and pass on those alleles, so hosts are selected for new defences: an evolutionary race.
Evasion mechanisms:
- Antigenic variation: mutation of surface antigen genes (influenza haemagglutinin, HIV envelope) means earlier memory cells and antibodies no longer fit.
- Surviving inside phagocytes: Mycobacterium tuberculosis stops the phagosome fusing with lysosomes.
- Hiding inside host cells: viruses and Plasmodium are out of reach of antibodies.
- 1
Host defence
phagocytes, antibodies and memory cells act as selection pressures
- 2
Pathogen mutation
some pathogens have alleles that help them evade defence
- 3
Survival and reproduction
these pathogens pass on the advantageous alleles
- 4
Host selected
hosts with better defences are selected in turn
Then back to step 1
Why does antigenic variation mean a person can catch influenza again?
Bacteriostatic and bactericidal
Bacteriostatic antibiotics stop bacteria reproducing so the immune system clears them; bactericidal antibiotics kill them directly.
Bacteriostatic antibiotics (such as tetracyclines) stop bacteria reproducing but do not kill them. The population stops growing and the immune system destroys the rest, so they work well in healthy patients. If removed, growth restarts.
Bactericidal antibiotics (such as penicillin) kill bacteria, so living numbers fall. They are preferred in severe infections and for weakened immune systems, for example after chemotherapy.
In a broth culture, a bacteriostatic antibiotic holds the viable count steady while a bactericidal one reduces it.
| Bacteriostatic | Bactericidal | |
|---|---|---|
| Effect on bacteria | Stops reproduction | Kills bacteria |
| Viable count in broth | Stays steady | Falls |
| Example | Tetracyclines | Penicillin |
| Best used | Healthy patients | Severe infections and weak immune systems |
Bacteriostatic
- Effect on bacteria:
- Stops reproduction
- Viable count in broth:
- Stays steady
- Example:
- Tetracyclines
- Best used:
- Healthy patients
Bactericidal
- Effect on bacteria:
- Kills bacteria
- Viable count in broth:
- Falls
- Example:
- Penicillin
- Best used:
- Severe infections and weak immune systems
Why is a bactericidal antibiotic preferred for a patient after chemotherapy?
Core practical 15: antibiotics
Antibiotic discs on a bacterial lawn give zones of inhibition; the larger the zone area, the more susceptible the bacteria.
Spread a lawn of a non-pathogenic bacterium on sterile nutrient agar using aseptic technique. Place sterile paper discs soaked in different antibiotics on the agar with sterile forceps, plus a control disc soaked in sterile water.
Tape the lid in two or three places, not sealed, so oxygen enters and anaerobic pathogens do not grow. Incubate upside down at 25 °C (no higher than 30 °C) to reduce the risk of growing human pathogens.
Clear zones of inhibition show where bacteria did not grow. A larger zone means more susceptible bacteria.
- 1
Spread a lawn
of bacteria on sterile agar using aseptic technique
- 2
Add discs
antibiotic discs and a control disc, using sterile forceps
- 3
Tape the lid
in two or three places, not sealed
- 4
Incubate
upside down at 25 °C
- 5
Measure
the diameter of each clear zone of inhibition
Worked example
A zone of inhibition has a diameter of 18 mm. Calculate its area.
- 1
Radius = 18 ÷ 2 = 9 mm.
- 2
Area = .
- 3
, which is 254 mm² to three significant figures.
What is the purpose of the control disc soaked in sterile water?
How antibiotic resistance arises
A random mutation gives resistance, the antibiotic selects resistant bacteria, and the allele spreads by reproduction or on plasmids.
Random mutation can give a bacterium a resistance allele. An antibiotic acts as a selection pressure: susceptible bacteria die or stop growing, while resistant ones survive, reproduce and pass on the allele by vertical transmission.
Resistance genes on plasmids can also pass to other bacteria, even of other species, by horizontal transfer.
Misuse makes this worse: prescribing for viral infections, unnecessary broad-spectrum use, and patients not completing the course. MRSA (meticillin-resistant Staphylococcus aureus) is a well-known example.
- 1
Mutation
a bacterium gains an allele for resistance
- 2
Antibiotic used
susceptible bacteria die or stop growing
- 3
Resistant survive
they reproduce and pass on the allele
- 4
Spread
by vertical transmission, or on plasmids by horizontal transfer
Why should patients complete a full course of antibiotics?
Hospital infections and codes of practice
Hospitals have vulnerable patients and heavy antibiotic use, so codes of practice control prescribing and infection spread.
Hospital acquired infections (such as MRSA and Clostridioides difficile) arise because hospitals contain many vulnerable patients, open wounds and invasive equipment, heavy antibiotic use that selects for resistance, and many chances for cross-infection.
Understanding these causes has led to codes of practice: rules for antibiotic prescribing and for infection prevention and control.
Antibiotic prescribing
- Only prescribe when needed
- Use narrow-spectrum antibiotics where possible
- Test sensitivity
- Make sure the full course is completed
Infection prevention and control
- Hand washing and alcohol gel between patients
- Screening on admission, isolating infected patients
- Cleaning surfaces, sterilising instruments
- Restricting visitors
Give one reason why narrow-spectrum antibiotics are preferred where possible.
Try an exam question
Explain how antibiotic resistance develops in a population of bacteria and describe two measures that reduce its spread.
[5 marks]
- [1]A random mutation gives some bacteria a resistance allele.
- [1]The antibiotic is a selection pressure: susceptible bacteria die, resistant bacteria survive and reproduce.
- [1]The resistance allele is passed on to offspring and may spread to other bacteria on plasmids.
- [1]One measure: only prescribe antibiotics when needed and complete the full course.
- [1]Another measure: infection control such as hand washing, isolating infected patients and screening.
That's the notes covered.
Carry on to the next subtopic.
Try a question
Which of the following is the most appropriate negative control for this investigation?
1 mark, marked against the mark scheme
Which of the following is the most appropriate negative control for this investigation?
1 mark, marked against the mark scheme