Classification and phylogeny

Classification and phylogeny

Spec 4.6 · Edexcel A-Level Biology A: Revision notes

Studying this course? Keep your progress in one place.

Key facts

  • Phylogeny is worked out from phenotype (observable features) and genotype (DNA and protein sequences). Sequences are more reliable.
  • Classification sorts organisms into a hierarchy of groups: domain, kingdom, phylum, class, order, family, genus, species.
  • A species is a group of organisms that can interbreed to produce fertile offspring.
  • Each species has a two-part binomial name: genus, then species (Homo sapiens).
  • New evidence only changes classification after peer review and independent repetition.
  • Woese’s rRNA evidence led to the three domains: Bacteria, Archaea and Eukaryota.

Why we classify

Classification groups organisms by how closely related they are, using a hierarchy of taxa, and each species gets a two-part binomial name.

Related organisms share a common ancestor: the more recently they shared it, the more closely related they are. The study of these evolutionary relationships is phylogeny.

Classification places organisms in a hierarchy of taxa. Each species is named by its binomial: the genus, then the species, for example Homo sapiens.

  1. 1

    Domain

    largest group

  2. 2

    Kingdom

  3. 3

    Phylum

  4. 4

    Class

  5. 5

    Order

  6. 6

    Family

  7. 7

    Genus

    first part of the binomial

  8. 8

    Species

    second part of the binomial

The taxonomic hierarchy, largest group to smallest

Which two parts make up a binomial?

The species concept

A species is a group of organisms that can interbreed to produce fertile offspring, but this definition cannot be tested in every case.

A species is a group of organisms that can interbreed to produce fertile offspring.

The definition has limits:

  • it cannot be applied to organisms that reproduce asexually, such as bacteria
  • it cannot be tested on extinct organisms known only from fossils
  • some different species interbreed to produce hybrids
  • populations that live apart cannot easily be tested

In these cases differences in phenotype and genotype are used instead.

  1. 1

    Can they interbreed?

    mate and produce offspring

  2. 2

    Is the offspring fertile?

    yes: same species; no (e.g. a mule): different species

  3. 3

    Cannot test

    asexual, extinct or living apart

  4. 4

    Compare instead

    phenotype and genotype differences

Deciding whether two organisms are the same species, and what to do when the test cannot be used.
  • Same speciesinterbreed
  • Offspringfertile

Why can the interbreeding definition of a species not be used for bacteria?

Phenotype and genotype

Phenotypic evidence (observable features) can mislead, while genotypic evidence (DNA and protein sequences) is objective and more reliable.

Phenotype evidence covers anatomy, morphology (such as limb bones), behaviour (such as courtship calls), biochemistry and cell structure. It can mislead: unrelated organisms in similar environments may evolve similar features (convergent evolution).

Genotype evidence compares DNA or RNA base sequences (such as the rRNA gene) and amino acid sequences (such as cytochrome c). More differences mean more mutations have built up, so the common ancestor was longer ago. A phylogenetic tree shows the result, with branch points as common ancestors.

0102030401ChimpanzeeRhesus monkeyDogHorseChickenTunaYeastOrganismAmino acid differences from human
Cytochrome c amino acid differences from humans (typical textbook values): more differences mean the common ancestor was longer ago.

Phenotypic evidence

What is compared:
Observable features
Reliability:
Can be misleading
Environment:
Affected by the environment

Genotypic evidence

What is compared:
Base and amino acid sequences
Reliability:
Objective and comparable
Environment:
Not affected by the environment

Species X and Y have 2 differences in their cytochrome c sequence. X and Z have 14 differences. Which pair shared a common ancestor more recently?

Evaluating new evidence

New data changes a classification only after experts have checked it and other scientists have found independent evidence.

Before a classification is changed, other scientists critically evaluate the new data:

  • experts check the work through peer review before publication
  • other scientists repeat it and look for independent evidence
  • they check that the conclusions are supported by the data and free from bias or error

If the community accepts the evidence, the classification is revised. If not, the claim is rejected or revised. This keeps classification based on reliable evidence.

  1. 1

    New data

    published for evaluation

  2. 2

    Peer review

    experts check the methods and conclusions

  3. 3

    Repeated by others

    independent evidence sought

  4. 4

    Accepted or rejected

    classification revised only if accepted

How new evidence changes classification

Why is repetition by other scientists important before a classification is changed?

The three domains

Woese’s ribosomal RNA evidence showed the Archaea differ greatly from the true bacteria, so life is now split into three domains.

Until the 1970s organisms were put in five kingdoms, with all prokaryotes in one.

In 1977 Carl Woese compared ribosomal RNA base sequences and found that the Archaea were very different from the true bacteria. Later work, such as different lipids in archaeal membranes, supported this.

The three domains are Bacteria, Archaea and Eukaryota. The system rests on molecular phylogeny and was accepted after evaluation by the scientific community.

Bacteria

Prokaryote:
Yes
Peptidoglycan cell wall:
Yes

Archaea

Prokaryote:
Yes
Peptidoglycan cell wall:
No

Eukaryota

Prokaryote:
No
Peptidoglycan cell wall:
No
  1. Before 1970s

    Five kingdoms

    All prokaryotes in one kingdom.

  2. 1977

    Woese

    Compares rRNA base sequences; Archaea differ from bacteria.

  3. Later

    Support

    Archaeal membrane lipids are different too.

  4. Now

    Three domains

    Bacteria, Archaea and Eukaryota.

What evidence led Woese to propose that the Archaea are a separate group?

Try an exam question

Explain why the classification of organisms is sometimes changed, and why DNA sequence evidence is more reliable than phenotype.

[4 marks]

That's the notes covered.

Carry on to the next subtopic.

Try a question

Which of these is the best definition of a species?

1 mark, marked against the mark scheme

Revision notes