Evolution, speciation and scientific validation

Evolution, speciation and scientific validation

Spec 5.17–19 · Edexcel A-Level Biology A: Revision notes

Studying this course? Keep your progress in one place.

Key facts

  • Evolution is a change in allele frequency in a population over generations; individuals do not evolve.
  • Mutation makes new alleles at random; natural selection changes their frequency.
  • Journals, peer review and conferences validate new evidence; conclusions need repeating by others.
  • Genomics (DNA) and proteomics (amino acids) show fewer differences between more closely related species.
  • Isolation reduces gene flow; divergence can lead to new species that cannot produce fertile offspring.
  • Allopatric speciation needs a geographical barrier; sympatric happens in the same area.

Evolution and allele frequency

Evolution is a change in the allele frequency of a population over generations, so populations evolve, not individuals.

A population is a group of interbreeding individuals of one species in an area. Its gene pool is all the alleles of all its genes. Allele frequency is how common an allele is in the gene pool.

Evolution is a change in allele frequency in a population over generations. Evolution comes about through gene mutation and natural selection.

00.20.40.60.8110203040GenerationAllele frequency
A beneficial allele becoming more common in a population (illustrative values)
  • Evolutionchange in allele frequency of a population over generations

Which of these evolves?

Mutation and natural selection

Random mutations give new alleles, and selection pressures make advantageous alleles more common over generations.

A gene mutation is a change in the base sequence of a gene. It is random and can give a new allele that is harmful, neutral or advantageous.

Natural selection then acts on the variation. Examples: antibiotic resistance in bacteria, where a resistance allele that arose by mutation becomes common when antibiotics are used, and dark peppered moths on soot-darkened trees, where camouflage reduces predation by birds.

  1. 1

    Variation

    the population has different alleles

  2. 2

    Selection pressure

    a predator, disease or antibiotic

  3. 3

    Survival

    individuals with an advantageous allele survive and reproduce

  4. 4

    Inheritance

    they pass the allele to their offspring

  5. 5

    Allele frequency

    over generations the allele frequency increases

Natural selection

Why do bacteria become resistant to an antibiotic?

Validating evidence

Journals, peer review and conferences let the scientific community check evidence, and repetition by others confirms it.

New evidence becomes accepted theory when the scientific community has checked it.

  • Scientific journals publish reports so others can read and use them.
  • Peer review: before publication, independent experts check the methods, data, analysis and conclusions, reducing bias and error.
  • Conferences: scientists present findings in talks and posters, answer questions and get feedback. Results are challenged and may be repeated.

Conclusions are accepted when results are repeated and supported by other independent research.

  1. 1

    Research

    carried out and written up

  2. 2

    Peer review

    independent experts check methods, data and conclusions

  3. 3

    Publication

    in a scientific journal

  4. 4

    Conferences

    findings presented, questioned and discussed

  5. 5

    Repeated

    other independent research supports the conclusions

Validating evidence

What is the purpose of peer review?

Genomics and proteomics

Fewer differences in DNA or protein sequences mean two species shared a common ancestor more recently, matching fossil and anatomical evidence.

Genomics compares the base sequences of DNA (genomes) of different species. Proteomics compares the amino acid sequences of proteins, such as haemoglobin or cytochrome c.

The fewer the differences, the more recently two species shared a common ancestor. This supports the theory of evolution because the pattern matches relationships from fossils and anatomy.

The data are validated by publication, peer review and repetition by other laboratories.

0102030401ChimpanzeeMonkeyDogChickenYeastSpecies compared with humanAmino acid differences
Fewer differences in a protein sequence from humans means a more recent common ancestor (illustrative values)
  • Fewer differencesmore recent common ancestor

Worked example

Species A and B differ by 1 amino acid in a protein, and A and C differ by 14. Which pair share the more recent common ancestor?

Species X and Y differ by 3 amino acids; X and Z differ by 9. Which is more closely related to X?

Isolation and gene flow

Isolation reduces gene flow, so populations accumulate different alleles until they can no longer interbreed to produce fertile offspring.

Gene flow is the transfer of alleles between populations by interbreeding. When populations are isolated, gene flow is reduced or stopped, so each population changes separately.

If populations become unable to interbreed and produce fertile offspring, they are different species. This is reproductive isolation.

  1. 1

    Isolation

    gene flow between populations is reduced or stopped

  2. 2

    Different mutations

    arise randomly in each population

  3. 3

    Different selection pressures

    favour different alleles

  4. 4

    Divergence

    allele frequencies diverge over many generations

  5. 5

    New species

    the populations can no longer interbreed to produce fertile offspring

How isolation leads to a new species

What is gene flow?

Allopatric and sympatric speciation

Allopatric speciation needs a geographical barrier; sympatric speciation happens in the same area through other isolating differences.

In both types there is reproductive isolation followed by genetic divergence. Different mutations and selection pressures cause divergence until the populations cannot interbreed.

Allopatric means "apart": a geographical barrier such as the sea, a mountain range or a river separates populations.

Sympatric means "same place": populations share an area but differ in breeding time, courtship behaviour, food or habitat choice, or chromosome number (common in plants).

  1. 1

    One interbreeding population

    Genes flow freely between members.

  2. 2

    Isolation

    A geographical barrier (allopatric) or a behaviour, timing or habitat difference (sympatric).

  3. 3

    Genetic divergence

    Different mutations and selection pressures act on each group.

  4. 4

    Reproductive isolation

    The groups can no longer interbreed: two species.

How one population becomes two species

Allopatric speciation

Where:
Populations separated
Isolation:
Geographical barrier
Gene flow:
None while separated

Sympatric speciation

Where:
Populations in the same area
Isolation:
Breeding time, behaviour, food, habitat or chromosome number
Gene flow:
Reduced, often incomplete at first

Two populations of a plant live in the same field but flower at different times. Which type of speciation is this?

Try an exam question

Explain how two populations of one species could become two separate species after being separated by a mountain range.

[5 marks]

That's the notes covered.

Carry on to the next subtopic.

Try a question

Which is the best definition of evolution?

1 mark, marked against the mark scheme

Revision notes