AQA A-Level Maths
Sampling
Total 27 marks
Name
Class
Date
- 1A researcher wants to estimate the mean time that students at a sixth-form college of 640 students take to travel to college. One morning she stands at the main entrance and asks the first 30 students who arrive.(a)Which sampling technique is the researcher using?[1 mark]
- ASimple random sampling
- BOpportunity sampling
- CA census
- DA pilot survey
Show the mark scheme
Mark scheme
Answer: B(b)What is the population in this investigation?[1 mark]- AThe 30 students who are asked
- BThe travel times of the 30 students
- CAll 640 students at the college
- DThe students who arrive early
Show the mark scheme
Mark scheme
Answer: C(c)Explain why the mean travel time of her sample may give a misleading estimate of the mean for the whole college.[2 marks]Show the mark scheme
Mark scheme
B1: students arriving first at the entrance are not a random selection (they may live nearer, or travel differently)
B1: so the sample is not representative, and its mean could be too low (or too high) compared with the population mean
Accept: not every student has a chance of being chosen; the sample is biased
Do not accept: the sample is too small, on its ownTotal for question 1: 4 marks
- 2A teacher has an alphabetical list of the 90 students in Year 12. She numbers them 01 to 90 and uses random numbers to choose a sample of 5 students.(a)Which statement must be true for her sample to be a simple random sample?[1 mark]
- AEvery student has the same chance of being selected, and every possible group of 5 is equally likely
- BStudents with consecutive numbers are selected together
- CThe first five students on the list are chosen
- DEqual numbers of boys and girls are chosen
Show the mark scheme
Mark scheme
Answer: A(b)The random number generator gives 47, 12, 47, 93, 05, 61, 88, 30 in that order. Repeats and numbers outside 01 to 90 are rejected. Which students are selected?[1 mark]- A47, 12, 47, 93, 05
- B12, 05, 61, 88, 30
- C47, 12, 93, 05, 61
- D47, 12, 05, 61, 88
Show the mark scheme
Mark scheme
Answer: D(c)Her sample of 5 contains 4 boys. The teacher concludes that most Year 12 students are boys. Explain why this conclusion is not justified.[2 marks]Show the mark scheme
Mark scheme
B1: the sample is very small (only 5 of 90), so a high proportion of boys could easily occur by chance
B1: a different random sample could give a different proportion, so one sample cannot establish what the whole year group is like
Accept: another sample might contain mostly girlsTotal for question 2: 4 marks
- 3A town has 24 000 registered voters. A polling company wants to estimate the proportion who support a new bypass. Method X: phone 200 voters chosen by applying random numbers to the electoral register. Method Y: ask the first 200 people who walk past a shopping centre on a Saturday morning.(a)Compare the two methods, and state which is more likely to give a representative sample of voters.[3 marks]
Show the mark scheme
Mark scheme
B1: Method X is simple random sampling: every registered voter has an equal chance of being chosen
B1: Method Y is opportunity sampling: only people who happen to be at the shopping centre then can be chosen, so some groups are missing or over-represented (e.g. people working on Saturday)
B1: conclusion: X is more likely to be representative (less biased); Y is quicker and cheaper but may be biased
Accept: X needs the electoral register, which may be out of date(b)Using Method X, 124 of the 200 voters in a sample support the bypass. A second simple random sample of 200 voters gives 110 supporters. Use each sample to estimate the number of supporters among the 24 000 voters, and explain why the estimates differ.[4 marks]Show the mark scheme
Mark scheme
B1: first estimate:
B1: second estimate:
B1: different samples contain different voters, so sample proportions vary
B1: neither estimate is wrong: each is only an informal estimate of the population value (a larger sample would be expected to be more reliable)
Accept: 14 900 and 13 200Total for question 3: 7 marks
- 4A company has 2400 employees, listed in a spreadsheet and numbered 1 to 2400, with the 1500 factory workers first and the 900 office workers last. A manager wants to survey 60 employees about a new shift pattern.(a)(i) Describe how random numbers could be used to select a simple random sample of 60 employees.[6 marks]
(ii) Instead, the manager asks the first 60 employees to enter the factory canteen at lunchtime. Name this technique and give one reason why the results may be biased.
(iii) The population proportion of factory workers is . A simple random sample of 60 contains 41 factory workers. Show that the sample proportion is higher than and explain whether this shows the method is biased.Show the mark scheme
Mark scheme
B1: (i) generate random numbers between 1 and 2400 (e.g. four-digit numbers, rejecting 0000 and numbers above 2400), selecting that employee number
B1: (i) reject repeats and continue until 60 different employees have been chosen
B1: (ii) opportunity sampling
R1: (ii) only employees in the factory canteen at lunchtime can be chosen, so office staff and anyone on another shift are under-represented
B1: (iii) (3 s.f.), which is greater than
R1: (iii) a small difference of this size can occur by chance in a random sample; it is not evidence of bias
Accept: a different sample would give a different proportion(b)Three independent simple random samples of 60 employees are taken. In favour of the new shift pattern: 27 in the first, 31 in the second and 22 in the third. The manager says that, because the second sample shows a majority in favour, most employees want the new pattern.[6 marks]
(i) Combine the three samples to estimate the number of the 2400 employees in favour.
(ii) Evaluate the manager's claim.Show the mark scheme
Mark scheme
M1: (i) in favour out of
A1: (i) proportion
M1: (i)
A1: (i) about employees (1067)
R1: (ii) the second sample alone gives , but the other samples do not show a majority, so different samples give different conclusions
R1: (ii) the combined, larger sample suggests a minority in favour, so the claim is not supported
Accept: 1067, 1070, 1100Total for question 4: 12 marks
End of questions