Edexcel A-Level Further Maths
Decision trees and expected monetary value
Total 27 marks
Name
Class
Date
- 1A florist must decide whether to order a large or a small stock of roses for a weekend. The weather will be fine with probability 0.6 or poor with probability 0.4. A large stock gives a profit of £800 if the weather is fine and £200 if it is poor. A small stock gives a profit of £500 if fine and £350 if poor.(a)Find the expected monetary value (EMV) of ordering a large stock.[1 mark]
- A£440
- B£560
- C£500
- D£1000
Show the mark scheme
Mark scheme
Answer: B(b)To maximise EMV, which course of action should the florist choose?[1 mark]- ASmall stock, because its worst outcome is better
- BLarge stock, because its best outcome is £800
- CSmall stock, because its EMV is £440
- DLarge stock, because its EMV of £560 is greater than £440
Show the mark scheme
Mark scheme
Answer: D(c)The probability of fine weather is instead of . Find the value of for which the two stock sizes have the same EMV.[2 marks]Show the mark scheme
Mark scheme
M1: , i.e.
A1:
Accept: orTotal for question 1: 4 marks
- 2A company must choose between two projects. Project X gives a certain profit of £40 000. Project Y gives a profit of £100 000 with probability 0.5, and otherwise a loss of £20 000.(a)Find the EMV of Project Y.[1 mark]
- A£60 000
- B£80 000
- C£40 000
- D£50 000
Show the mark scheme
Mark scheme
Answer: C(b)Based on EMV alone, which statement is correct?[1 mark]- AThe company is indifferent between X and Y, as both have an EMV of £40 000
- BThe company should choose X, as it has no risk
- CThe company should choose Y, as it could make £100 000
- DThe company should choose neither, as Y could make a loss
Show the mark scheme
Mark scheme
Answer: A(c)The directors assign a utility of 0 to a loss of £20 000, 0.8 to a profit of £40 000 and 1 to a profit of £100 000. Calculate the expected utility of each project and state which the company should choose.[2 marks]Show the mark scheme
Mark scheme
M1: expected utility of Y
A1: X has utility , so choose Project X
Accept: a comment that the company is risk averseTotal for question 2: 4 marks
- 3A software firm is deciding whether to launch a new app. Without any research, the probability that the app succeeds is 0.5. A success gives a profit of £120 000 and a failure gives a loss of £50 000; not launching gives £0. Alternatively, the firm can first pay £10 000 for a market survey. The survey result is favourable with probability 0.6, and then the probability of success is 0.75; otherwise it is unfavourable, and then the probability of success is 0.125. The profits and losses above do not include the cost of the survey.(a)Find the EMV of launching the app after an unfavourable survey result, and state the decision the firm should then make.[3 marks]
Show the mark scheme
Mark scheme
M1:
A1:
B1: do not launch, since
Accept: follow-through from their EMV, if it is negative(b)Determine whether the firm should commission the survey. Show the value at each node you use.[4 marks]Show the mark scheme
Mark scheme
M1: favourable launch EMV
A1: £77 500, so launch (greater than 0)
M1: survey node minus £10 000
Accept: follow-through from their value for the unfavourable branch
A1: £36 500 compared with the no-survey EMV of £35 000 (), so commission the surveyTotal for question 3: 7 marks
- 4A mining company must decide whether to drill at a site. Drilling costs £2 million. If it drills, there is a 0.3 probability of a major find with revenue £12 million, a 0.45 probability of a minor find with revenue £4 million, and a 0.25 probability of finding nothing (revenue £0). Alternatively, the company can sell its drilling rights for a certain £1.5 million.(a)(i) State the pay-off at each end node of the drilling branch.[6 marks]
(ii) Find the EMV of drilling and the value at the decision node.
(iii) Explain why the value at the decision node is the larger of two values, while the value at the chance node is a weighted average.Show the mark scheme
Mark scheme
B1: (i) pay-offs £10 million, £2 million and £2 million (revenue less the £2 million cost)
M1: (ii)
A1: (ii) EMV of drilling is £3.4 million
B1: (ii) decision node value is £3.4 million, since it is greater than £1.5 million, so drill
B1: (iii) at a decision node the company chooses the branch, so it takes the most favourable value
B1: (iii) at a chance node the company cannot choose the outcome, so the outcomes are weighted by their probabilities
Accept: follow-through from their pay-offs(b)The company's directors are risk averse. They assign a utility of 0 to £2 million, 0.6 to £1.5 million, 0.65 to £2 million and 1 to £10 million. Evaluate whether the company should drill, using expected utility, and compare your conclusion with the EMV decision.[6 marks]Show the mark scheme
Mark scheme
M1: expected utility of drilling
A1:
B1: selling has utility (certain)
B1: , so sell the rights on the utility criterion
B1: EMV chooses to drill (), so the two criteria disagree
B1: utility takes account of the attitude to risk (a 25% chance of losing £2 million); the margin is small, so the decision is sensitive to the utility values
Accept: a valid comment on the diminishing value of money for a risk-averse companyTotal for question 4: 12 marks
End of questions