Modelling with probability

Modelling with probability

Spec 3.3 · Edexcel A-Level Maths: Revision notes

Studying this course? Keep your progress in one place.

Key facts

  • A model is a simplified description of a situation built from assumptions; answers are only as good as the assumptions.
  • Common assumptions: a fair die or coin, independent trials, constant probability.
  • Criticise an assumption by naming it, saying why it is doubtful here, and stating the likely effect.
  • A binomial model X∼B(n,p)X\sim B(n,p) needs fixed nn, two outcomes, constant pp and independent trials.
  • Compare expected with observed results to test a model.

What a probability model is

A model uses assumptions to let you calculate probabilities.

A model is a simplified description of a real situation, built from assumptions. Common ones are that a coin or die is fair, that trials are independent, and that the probability stays constant.

Modelling two die rolls with a fair die gives P(sum=7)=636P(\text{sum}=7)=\frac{6}{36}. All the working in a model question is done inside the model.

  1. 1

    Real situation

    Describe what is happening.

  2. 2

    Assumptions

    Fair, independent, constant probability.

  3. 3

    Model

    Choose a distribution or sample space.

  4. 4

    Calculate

    Work out the probabilities.

  5. 5

    Check

    Compare with the data and criticise.

Modelling cycle

Which is an assumption of the fair-die model?

Critiquing assumptions

Name the assumption, say why it is doubtful in this context, and state the likely effect.

Be specific to the context. Real dice and coins can be biased. Independence fails when a common cause links events, such as traffic delaying consecutive buses. Constant probability can vary with time, weather or form.

A good answer names the assumption, says why it is doubtful here, and states the likely effect.

246810120.20.40.60.81xyconstant p = 0.5p varying with the month
A constant probability (dashed) against one that varies through the year (illustrative values): the constant-probability assumption can fail

Assumption

  • Fair die or coin
  • Independence
  • Constant probability

Why it may fail

  • Real ones can be biased
  • A common cause links events
  • It varies with time, weather or form

A model assumes a bus is late with the same probability each day. Which criticism is best?

Using distributions to model situations

Check the conditions before choosing: a binomial model needs a fixed number of independent trials with constant pp.

A binomial model X∼B(n,p)X\sim B(n,p) needs a fixed number of trials, two outcomes, constant pp and independence. A discrete uniform model suits a fair die, giving each value 1n\frac1n.

A discrete model given as a table is valid if its probabilities sum to 1. For a continuous variable, probabilities are areas under a curve.

00.050.10.150.20.250.3012345Number of successes rP(X = r)
Probabilities for X ~ B(5, 0.5), a fixed number of independent trials with constant p
  • BinomialP(X=r)=(nr)pr(1−p)n−rP(X=r)=\binom nr p^r(1-p)^{n-r}

Worked example

X∼B(10,0.7)X\sim B(10,0.7). Find P(X=7)P(X=7) and P(X≥8)P(X\ge8).

Which situation is a binomial model?

Comparing a model with data

Compute the expected result and compare it with what was observed.

The expected value is the result predicted by the model, n×pn\times p in nn trials. The observed value is what actually happened.

A fair die rolled 60 times gives an expected 10 sixes; 18 sixes is far more, so the ‘fair’ assumption looks doubtful. Small samples give weak evidence, so say a larger sample would help.

051015ExpectedObservedResultNumber of sixes
Number of sixes in 60 rolls of a die: expected from the model against observed
  • Expected numbern×pn\times p

A fair die is rolled 60 times. How many sixes do you expect?

Try an exam question

The number XX of days out of 88 on which a bus is late is modelled by B(8,0.25)B(8,0.25). State two assumptions of this model and find P(X=2)P(X=2).

[4 marks]

That's the notes covered.

Carry on to the next subtopic.

Try a question

Using the model, find the probability that the total of the two rolls is 7.

1 mark, marked against the mark scheme

Revision notes