Harmonic form and trigonometric proof

Harmonic form and trigonometric proof

Spec 5.6 · Edexcel A-Level Maths: Revision notes

Studying this course? Keep your progress in one place.

Key facts

  • Harmonic form writes acos⁡θ+bsin⁡θa\cos\theta+b\sin\theta as Rcos⁡(θ−α)R\cos(\theta-\alpha) or Rsin⁡(θ+α)R\sin(\theta+\alpha).
  • R=a2+b2R=\sqrt{a^2+b^2}, with Rcos⁡α=aR\cos\alpha=a and Rsin⁡α=bR\sin\alpha=b from expanding the form.
  • The maximum is RR and the minimum is −R-R; if ∣c∣>R|c|>R, acos⁡θ+bsin⁡θ=ca\cos\theta+b\sin\theta=c has no solution.
  • Prove identities from one side only, citing the identity used at each step.
  • Factorise rather than divide, or you lose solutions.

Harmonic form

Two waves of the same period combine into one wave Rcos⁡(θ−α)R\cos(\theta-\alpha).

R>0R>0 is the amplitude and α\alpha the phase shift (acute unless told otherwise). Harmonic form is useful because a single trig function is easy to solve and its extreme values are simply ±R\pm R.

123456−1.5−1−0.50.511.5xymax (45°, √2)y = cos xy = sin xy = cos x + sin x
cos x + sin x (solid) = √2 cos(x − 45°), amplitude √2 (x in radians).
  • acos⁡θ+bsin⁡θa\cos\theta+b\sin\thetaRcos⁡(θ−α)R\cos(\theta-\alpha) or Rsin⁡(θ+α)R\sin(\theta+\alpha)

What is RR for 5cos⁡θ+12sin⁡θ5\cos\theta+12\sin\theta?

Finding R and α

Expand the form you want with a compound formula and compare coefficients.

Rcos⁡(θ−α)=Rcos⁡θcos⁡α+Rsin⁡θsin⁡αR\cos(\theta-\alpha)=R\cos\theta\cos\alpha+R\sin\theta\sin\alpha, so Rcos⁡α=aR\cos\alpha=a and Rsin⁡α=bR\sin\alpha=b, giving R=a2+b2R=\sqrt{a^2+b^2} and tan⁡α=ba\tan\alpha=\dfrac ba.

In each form below Rcos⁡α=aR\cos\alpha=a and Rsin⁡α=bR\sin\alpha=b. Use sin⁡\sin over cos⁡\cos from your own expansion, and check by expanding again.

72425αABC
For 7 cos θ − 24 sin θ: R = 25, tan α = 24/7, so α = 73.74°.

Worked example

Write 7cos⁡θ−24sin⁡θ7\cos\theta-24\sin\theta in the form Rcos⁡(θ+α)R\cos(\theta+\alpha).

Worked example

Express sin⁡x−3cos⁡x\sin x-\sqrt3\cos x as Rsin⁡(x−α)R\sin(x-\alpha) with xx in radians, then solve sin⁡x−3cos⁡x=1\sin x-\sqrt3\cos x=1 for 0≤x<2π0\le x<2\pi.

a cos θ + b sin θ

  • R cos(θ − α)

a cos θ − b sin θ

  • R cos(θ + α)

a sin θ + b cos θ

  • R sin(θ + α)

a sin θ − b cos θ

  • R sin(θ − α)

For 5cos⁡θ+12sin⁡θ=Rcos⁡(θ−α)5\cos\theta+12\sin\theta=R\cos(\theta-\alpha), what is α\alpha?

Using harmonic form

Once written as Rcos⁡(θ−α)R\cos(\theta-\alpha), the maximum is RR, the minimum −R-R, and equations become one trig function.

The maximum RR occurs when θ−α=0∘\theta-\alpha=0^\circ, and the minimum −R-R when θ−α=180∘\theta-\alpha=180^\circ.

To solve acos⁡θ+bsin⁡θ=ca\cos\theta+b\sin\theta=c use cos⁡(θ−α)=cR\cos(\theta-\alpha)=\dfrac cR, working out the range of θ−α\theta-\alpha first. If ∣c∣>R|c|>R there is no solution. A fraction kp+acos⁡θ+bsin⁡θ\dfrac{k}{p+a\cos\theta+b\sin\theta} is greatest when the denominator is least.

123456−6−4−2246xyy = Ry = −Rmax (0.927, 5)min (4.069, −5)y = 3 cos x + 4 sin x
y = 3 cos x + 4 sin x ranges between −5 and 5; maximum at x = 0.927.

What is the greatest value of 110+3cos⁡θ+4sin⁡θ\dfrac{1}{10+3\cos\theta+4\sin\theta}?

Constructing proofs

Start from one side and transform it step by step into the other, stating the identity used each time.

A proof never treats the identity as true and works on both sides. Useful tools: tan⁡θ=sin⁡θcos⁡θ\tan\theta=\dfrac{\sin\theta}{\cos\theta}, sin⁡2θ+cos⁡2θ=1\sin^2\theta+\cos^2\theta=1, the double angle formulae, and the compound formulae in either direction.

Example: cos⁡xcos⁡2x+sin⁡xsin⁡2x=cos⁡(2x−x)=cos⁡x\cos x\cos2x+\sin x\sin2x=\cos(2x-x)=\cos x. An identity uses ≡\equiv.

Do not cancel terms that are added.

−1.2−1−0.8−0.6−0.4−0.200.20.40.60.811.21.4−6−4−2246xysin 2θ ÷ (1 + cos 2θ)tan θ
The two sides of sin 2θ ÷ (1 + cos 2θ) ≡ tan θ trace the same curve (tan θ dashed).
  • 1+cos⁡2θ1+\cos2\theta2cos⁡2θ2\cos^2\theta
  • 1−cos⁡2θ1-\cos2\theta2sin⁡2θ2\sin^2\theta

Worked proof

Prove that sin⁡2θ1+cos⁡2θ≡tan⁡θ\dfrac{\sin2\theta}{1+\cos2\theta}\equiv\tan\theta.

Simplify 1−cos⁡2θsin⁡2θ\dfrac{1-\cos2\theta}{\sin2\theta}.

From proof to equations

Use the identity to simplify the equation, then factorise rather than divide.

Once sin⁡2θ1+cos⁡2θ≡tan⁡θ\dfrac{\sin2\theta}{1+\cos2\theta}\equiv\tan\theta is proved, sin⁡2θ1+cos⁡2θ=3tan⁡2θ\dfrac{\sin2\theta}{1+\cos2\theta}=3\tan^2\theta becomes tan⁡θ=3tan⁡2θ\tan\theta=3\tan^2\theta.

Factorise as tan⁡θ(3tan⁡θ−1)=0\tan\theta(3\tan\theta-1)=0. Dividing by tan⁡θ\tan\theta would lose the solutions where tan⁡θ=0\tan\theta=0.

  1. 1

    Prove

    the identity

  2. 2

    Substitute

    into the equation

  3. 3

    Factorise

    do not divide

  4. 4

    Solve

    each factor in the interval

Proof then solve

Worked example

Solve sin⁡2θ1+cos⁡2θ=3tan⁡2θ\dfrac{\sin2\theta}{1+\cos2\theta}=3\tan^2\theta for 0≤θ<360∘0\le\theta<360^\circ.

Why factorise tan⁡θ=3tan⁡2θ\tan\theta=3\tan^2\theta instead of dividing by tan⁡θ\tan\theta?

Try an exam question

Express 7cos⁡θ−24sin⁡θ7\cos\theta-24\sin\theta in the form Rcos⁡(θ+α)R\cos(\theta+\alpha), where R>0R>0 and 0<α<90∘0<\alpha<90^\circ, giving α\alpha to 2 decimal places. Hence write down the minimum value of 7cos⁡θ−24sin⁡θ7\cos\theta-24\sin\theta.

[4 marks]

That's the notes covered.

Carry on to the next subtopic.

Try a question

Write h(θ)h(\theta) in the form Rcos⁡(θ+α)R\cos(\theta+\alpha), where R>0R>0 and α\alpha is acute. Find RR.

1 mark, marked against the mark scheme

Revision notes