Mathematical modelling in mechanics
Studying this course? Keep your progress in one place.
Key facts
- Mathematical modelling turns a real situation into a simplified problem you can solve.
- Every assumption has a consequence: say what it ignores and which way the prediction is wrong.
- A particle has mass but no size; a light string or pulley has negligible mass.
- An inextensible string does not stretch, so connected particles share speed and acceleration.
- A smooth surface gives no friction; ignoring air resistance makes predicted speeds too large.
The modelling cycle
Modelling means simplifying a real situation, solving the maths, then comparing the result with reality and refining the model.
Mathematical modelling means turning a real situation into a simplified mathematical problem so that it can be solved.
Every model is a simplification, so you must be able to say what each assumption means for the forces and motion, and in which direction it makes the prediction wrong.
Compare the answer with real data. If it does not fit, refine the model and go round again.
- 1
Real problem
describe the situation
- 2
Make assumptions
simplify it
- 3
Build the model
write equations
- 4
Solve
find the predictions
- 5
Compare with reality
does it fit the data?
- 6
Refine
adjust the assumptions
Then back to step 1
What should you do if a model's predictions do not match real data?
Particle, lamina and rigid body
A particle has mass but no size, a lamina is a flat sheet, and a rigid body has size but does not bend.
A particle has mass but no size, so all of its mass is at one point. Rotation and size are ignored. Use it for a ball, a car or a person when their size is small compared with the distances involved.
A lamina is a flat object of negligible thickness, with mass spread over its area.
A rigid body is an object of finite size that does not bend or change shape.
A particle's weight acts at one point, with no turning effects.
Particle
- Mass at one point
- No size, no rotation
- Weight acts at one point
Lamina
- Flat, negligible thickness
- Mass spread over area
Rigid body
- Has finite size
- Does not bend or change shape
Which assumption means all the mass is at one point?
Rods, strings and pulleys
Light means negligible mass, uniform means evenly spread mass, and inextensible means the string does not stretch.
A rod is a long thin rigid body with length but no thickness. A light object has negligible mass. A uniform rod has its mass evenly distributed, so its weight acts at the midpoint. A non-uniform rod has its weight acting elsewhere.
An inextensible string does not stretch, so connected particles have the same speed and acceleration along it.
A light smooth pulley means equal tension on both sides.
| Light string | Inextensible | Light smooth pulley | Uniform rod | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| What it means | Negligible mass | Does not stretch | No mass, no friction | Mass evenly spread |
| What it gives you | Same tension throughout | Same speed and acceleration | Same tension both sides | Weight at the midpoint |
Light string
- What it means:
- Negligible mass
- What it gives you:
- Same tension throughout
Inextensible
- What it means:
- Does not stretch
- What it gives you:
- Same speed and acceleration
Light smooth pulley
- What it means:
- No mass, no friction
- What it gives you:
- Same tension both sides
Uniform rod
- What it means:
- Mass evenly spread
- What it gives you:
- Weight at the midpoint
Worked example
Masses of 3 kg and 5 kg hang from the ends of a light inextensible string over a light smooth pulley. Find the acceleration.
- 1
The tension is the same on both sides.
- 2
For 5 kg: . For 3 kg: .
- 3
Add: , so .
Why do connected particles on an inextensible string have the same acceleration?
Surfaces, beads, wires and pegs
Smooth means no friction, rough allows friction, and beads, wires and pegs give reactions perpendicular to the wire or string.
A smooth surface exerts no friction, only a normal reaction. A rough surface can exert friction, which opposes motion or tendency to move.
A bead is a particle with a hole through it, so it can slide along a wire, a thin rigid fixed support.
A peg is a fixed support of negligible size. A string over a smooth peg has unchanged tension.
Smooth surface
- Normal reaction only
- No friction
Rough surface
- Normal reaction
- Friction opposes motion
Bead on smooth wire
- Reaction perpendicular to wire
- No friction along wire
Smooth peg
- Reaction perpendicular to string
- Tension unchanged
What force does a smooth surface exert on a particle?
Criticising and refining a model
Link each assumption to a physical effect, then say whether the prediction is too large or too small.
To evaluate a model, link each assumption to a physical effect.
Ignoring air resistance makes predicted speeds and heights too large, because resistance opposes motion.
Refine by adding a resistance force, friction, a pulley mass or an extensible string, and compare the new predictions with data.
| No air resistance | Smooth floor | Light smooth pulley | Light inextensible string | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| What is ignored | A force opposing motion | Friction | Friction and pulley mass | Stretching and mass |
| Prediction | Speeds and heights too large | Accelerations too large | Acceleration too large | Fair for thin string, poor for rope |
No air resistance
- What is ignored:
- A force opposing motion
- Prediction:
- Speeds and heights too large
Smooth floor
- What is ignored:
- Friction
- Prediction:
- Accelerations too large
Light smooth pulley
- What is ignored:
- Friction and pulley mass
- Prediction:
- Acceleration too large
Light inextensible string
- What is ignored:
- Stretching and mass
- Prediction:
- Fair for thin string, poor for rope
A car is modelled with no air resistance. How does its predicted speed compare with the real speed?
Try an exam question
A toy truck is pulled along a rough horizontal table by a string that passes over a smooth pulley. The truck is modelled as a particle and the string as light. (a) State what is meant by modelling the truck as a particle. (b) State what is meant by a light string and what this implies about the tension. (c) The model ignores air resistance. Say how this affects the predicted acceleration.
[4 marks]
- [1]A particle has mass but no size: all of the mass is at one point.
- [1]A light string has negligible mass.
- [1]So the tension is the same throughout the string.
- [1]The predicted acceleration is too large, because air resistance opposes motion.
That's the notes covered.
Carry on to the next subtopic.
Try a question
Which statement describes what is assumed when the ball is modelled as a particle?
1 mark, marked against the mark scheme
Which statement describes what is assumed when the ball is modelled as a particle?
1 mark, marked against the mark scheme