Mathematical problem solving

Mathematical problem solving

Spec OT2.1–7 · AQA A-Level Maths: Revision notes

Studying this course? Keep your progress in one place.

Key facts

  • Problem solving is a cycle: specify, collect information, process and represent, interpret; repeat if the result is unreasonable.
  • Define variables and draw a labelled diagram before forming equations.
  • Unstructured problems: define variables, write the constraint, express the target in one variable, solve, then check.
  • Interpret results in context, with units, and discard answers outside the sensible domain.
  • Check reasonableness by estimating, and comment on assumptions and limitations.

The problem solving cycle

Specify the problem, collect information, process and represent it, then interpret; repeat if the result is unreasonable.

If the result is unreasonable or does not answer the question, repeat the problem solving cycle with a better specification or more data.

Written solutions should show the stages: define symbols, state equations, solve, then answer in words with units.

End every answer with a sentence in the language of the problem, including units.

  1. 1

    Specify

    decide exactly what is to be found

  2. 2

    Collect information

    gather the given data and any facts you need

  3. 3

    Process and represent

    draw a diagram, define variables, form equations, calculate

  4. 4

    Interpret

    say what the results mean in context

Then back to step 1

The problem solving cycle

Your answer is a negative length. What should you do?

Structure, abstraction and diagrams

Find the underlying structure, choose variables, and draw a labelled diagram.

Find the structure of the problem and strip it down (abstraction) by:

  • choosing variables ("let xx be the width in metres");
  • stating the quantities that are fixed (a total length, a rate);
  • identifying the type of mathematics: linear, quadratic, trigonometric.

Diagrams help you extract information, including sketches of shapes, forces or velocities. Label every known and unknown length, angle or force. Draw one first even if the question does not give one.

246810121416182050100150200xy(10, 200)A = 40x − 2x²
Area A=40x−2x2A=40x-2x^2 against xx, with its maximum at (10,200)(10,200).

Worked example

A garden is fenced on three sides with 40 m of fencing, the fourth side being a wall. The two sides touching the wall have length xx. Find the maximum area.

With xx the length of each side perpendicular to the wall and 40 m of fencing, what is the side parallel to the wall?

Extended and unstructured problems

Define variables, write the constraint, express the target in one variable, then solve and check.

An unstructured problem gives no steps, so plan it:

  1. Define variables and draw a diagram.
  2. Write the constraint (for example 2L+4w=1202L+4w=120).
  3. Write the quantity to find in terms of one variable (for example A=w(60−2w)A=w(60-2w)).
  4. Solve or optimise (completing the square or a graph).
  5. Check the solution makes sense.
  1. 1

    Define variables

    and draw a diagram

  2. 2

    Write the constraint

    for example a fixed length of fencing

  3. 3

    One-variable target

    express the quantity to find

  4. 4

    Solve or optimise

    complete the square or use a graph

  5. 5

    Check

    does the answer make sense?

Planning an unstructured problem

Worked example

120 m of fencing makes a rectangle with two internal dividers. Find the largest area, and the widths for which the area is at least 360 m2360\ \mathrm{m}^2.

In the fencing example, why is the constraint 2L+4w=1202L+4w=120 and not 2L+2w=1202L+2w=120?

Interpreting solutions in context

Discard answers that make no sense, give units and sensible rounding, and say what the number means.

A mathematical answer must be interpreted:

  • discard solutions that make no sense, such as a negative length;
  • give units and sensible rounding (usually 3 s.f.);
  • state the domain that is realistic for the variable;
  • say what the number means in the context.

If a quadratic gives roots x=−2x=-2 and x=5x=5 for a length in metres, only x=5x=5 fits.

123456785101520xy(3.75, 10.25)Firm A: 3.5 + 1.8dFirm B: 2 + 2.2d
Cost against distance for the two taxi firms.

Worked example

Firm A charges £3.50 plus £1.80 per mile. Firm B charges £2.00 plus £2.20 per mile. When are the costs equal, and which firm is cheaper for longer journeys?

A quadratic gives roots x=−2x=-2 and x=5x=5 for a length in metres. Which do you use?

Evaluating accuracy and limitations

Estimate with rounded numbers, and comment on the assumptions that limit the result.

Check an answer is reasonable by an estimate: round the numbers to 1 significant figure and compute roughly.

For a tank of radius 1.5 m and height 2.0 m, V=πr2h≈3×2×2=12 m3V=\pi r^2h\approx3\times2\times2=12\ \mathrm{m}^3, close to the exact 14.1 m314.1\ \mathrm{m}^3.

Comment on limitations: rounded inputs give rounded outputs, so quote results to suitable significant figures; assumptions such as constant rate or ideal shapes may not hold; a result outside the sensible domain means repeating the cycle.

If an estimate and your answer differ by a power of 10, find the slip.

02468101214Estimate (1 s.f.)ExactMethodVolume (m³)
Estimate against exact volume of the tank (r = 1.5 m, h = 2.0 m)

Estimate

  • Round to 1 significant figure
  • V≈3×2×2=12 m3V\approx3\times2\times2=12\ \mathrm{m}^3
  • Exact: 14.1 m314.1\ \mathrm{m}^3

Limitations

  • Rounded inputs give rounded outputs
  • Constant rate or ideal shape assumed
  • Result outside the domain: repeat the cycle

Worked example

Filling a 14 137-litre tank at a net 20 litres per minute: how long does it take, and how reliable is the answer?

Your exact answer is 1410 but an estimate gives about 14. What do you do?

Try an exam question

A farmer uses 4848 m of fencing to make a rectangular pen against a straight wall, fencing three sides. Each of the two sides touching the wall has length xx m. Find the maximum possible area of the pen.

[4 marks]

That's the notes covered.

Carry on to the next subtopic.

Try a question

Which expression gives AA in terms of xx?

1 mark, marked against the mark scheme

Revision notes